I don't fault Nelson for playing hurt.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 30, 2016
11:56:09am

Thrill All-American

I don't fault Nelson for playing hurt.

Guys play hurt all the time. Coaches need to have some sort of criteria they use to judge how much the injury will affect performance.

If a guy will not make the injury worse and he wants to play the coach has to determine if the guy is 50% or 95% or whatever.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 30, 2016 at 11:56:09am

Message modified by Thrill on Jun 30, 2016 at 12:28:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Thrill

Bio page: Thrill
Joined: Dec 1, 2001
Last login: Nov 22, 2024
Total posts: 57,912 (1,230 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I was surprised by the Taysom tidbit regarding his injury last year

BYU Fan

6/30/16 11:46am

This is totally different from RN

bluebloodedcoug

6/30/16 11:49am

There was an entire article about that just last week.

Superkid

6/30/16 11:53am

Also, RN's injury wasn't a huge deal eaither.......

PhilPete

6/30/16 11:55am

Painful, but not dangerous. His ribs, lung & shoulder were more debilitating.

mantis mutu

6/30/16 12:31pm

Broken back sounds devestating. Spinous or Transverse Process is played with a

coastcat

6/30/16 2:57pm

It's probably fair to note, however, that RN's own father (who is a Doctor) determined

Byron McNertney

6/30/16 11:56am

Interesting. I'm just going off the reports I've heard that it was a

bluebloodedcoug

6/30/16 11:59am

It always seemed really suspect to me, too, but I'm not a doctor so I don't know.

Byron McNertney

6/30/16 12:10pm

Also different is Taysom came out when he was ineffective and unable to go. Also

cougaman

6/30/16 12:06pm

At least with Taysom, it doesn't sound like safety was an issue.

6/30/16 11:49am

And once he became a liability on the field they pulled him and put in Tanner

bluebloodedcoug

6/30/16 11:50am

Taysom's injury could not get medically worse.

PhilPete

6/30/16 11:50am

You bring up a valid point. Taysom doesn't get called selfish for continuing to

Left Shark Coug

6/30/16 11:50am

That was said better than I was able to say it

BYU Fan

6/30/16 11:53am

I doubt the injury had anything to do with the pick

Coop

6/30/16 11:54am

I thought it was an LB, and the route wasn't exactly jumped. Taysom tossed the

Left Shark Coug

6/30/16 12:00pm

It was the safety; he pretended to bite on the PA, then dropped back quickly

Coop

6/30/16 12:36pm

He was still way out of position to make a play had it been a better pass.

Left Shark Coug

6/30/16 12:53pm

No, no, no, no

Coop

6/30/16 2:09pm

Agree to disagree.

Left Shark Coug

6/30/16 3:19pm

Well, we won the game.

bluebloodedcoug

6/30/16 11:55am

wasn't that his 5th interception that game? Oh...my bad, I confused him with...

icecougar

7/1/16 5:28pm

You were probably thinking Ty Detmer vs a bad Oregon team, except he wasn't

Left Shark Coug

7/1/16 5:55pm

hahaha...I remember that game. I was a student at BYU then....

icecougar

7/1/16 6:05pm

I didn't mention Riley at all. Perhaps you're a little sensitive.

Left Shark Coug

7/1/16 6:09pm

You replied to a post that did mention Riley comparing his injury with Taysom's

icecougar

7/1/16 7:37pm

Let the hate go, dude, let it go.

Left Shark Coug

7/1/16 8:05pm

It's been part of Staley's questions as well

I'mBatman

6/30/16 11:50am

Staley was also a victim of his own genetics.

Superkid

6/30/16 11:54am

Staley just sounds bitter. Takes no blame for his own decisions.

OptimisTIC

6/30/16 11:54am

Yet he backs it up with specific examples

I'mBatman

6/30/16 12:02pm

Hearing the details of the Staley situation made me wince...

icecougar

7/1/16 6:01pm

I don't fault Nelson for playing hurt.

Thrill

6/30/16 11:56am

I would say if a guy wants to play and will not make the injury worse, who is

crack

6/30/16 11:57am

I fault the coaches for EVER playing him in the first place.

RichieRich

6/30/16 11:58am

Players on the team at the time would tell you he earned it in practice.

Thrill

6/30/16 12:14pm

I agree. They never ask "Are you injured?" its always "Can you go?"

Deadpool

6/30/16 11:58am

Exactly. You should never fault a player for wanting to compete

whoneedscorners?

6/30/16 12:00pm

I don't fault Nelson for playing hurt

6/30/16 12:04pm

I fault the coaches for Riley playing hurt.

mudpupper

6/30/16 12:20pm

I don't fault RN for playing hurt. But at the same time, I also judge them how

rocker

6/30/16 12:25pm

and it's totally subjective since the coach doesn't feel what the injured...

icecougar

7/1/16 7:42pm

exactly. goes back to something i've always claimed...i NEVER will fault a

nashty

6/30/16 11:57am

Taysom and everyone else thought he could still contribute.

Accipiter

6/30/16 1:24pm

He was injured on the touchdown run in the second quarter. If you watch closely

oldrugger

6/30/16 4:16pm

Mangum said coaches told him in second quarter Taysom was out for yr & he

NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN

6/30/16 5:09pm

Did Taysom lie to the coaches about the severity of his injury?

Cyclogist

6/30/16 5:28pm

With the lis franc it's unlikely to get worse

ryebrye

6/30/16 6:14pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad