I would make the offense start sub prior to 25 sec on the clock. Ref holds snap

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 14, 2024
1:41:52pm

JAGA97 Intervention Needed

I would make the offense start sub prior to 25 sec on the clock. Ref holds snap

until 10. That gives each team 15 sec to sub. All these guys run sub 5 sec 40's so not a big deal.

Report problem with this ad

JAGA97

Bio page: JAGA97
Joined: Apr 10, 2008
Last login: Nov 14, 2024
Total posts: 25,426 (18 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A modest proposal to solve the late-subbing issue:

momowagon

1:30pm

So if they sub with 35 left on the play clock they still hold it until 5?

goidcougs

1:31pm

I say give the defense 12 seconds. Have the ref stopping it count it out with a

cougaman

1:34pm

Yeah. Defense gets the opportunity to sub. Maybe the times would change if it's

momowagon

1:34pm

They just need to limit the defense to 10 seconds to sub.

Zinger

1:34pm

Then someone has to track what time the D started subs.

momowagon

1:35pm

Doesn't seem too difficult. As soon as the Ref gets behind the Center to hold

Zinger

1:41pm

Too complicated. The current setup works for literally every team except one.

rcbyufan

1:36pm

Too complicated ... just stop the play clock with 5 sec to go until subs are done.

ManicBlue

1:38pm

what about the game clock? and is a Time out used or will it be a free time out

Cougar TD

1:42pm

Just stop it too if it's running. Probably won't happen much if the incentive to slow walk substitutions is gone.

ManicBlue

1:54pm

or just put the ball in play with 5 sec to go. Too bad if the defense isn't ready.

ManicBlue

1:55pm

The rule should be defense subs at their own risk. Problem solved.

byubyu

1:41pm

No. Defense should be able to match up late subs.

rcbyufan

1:48pm

Why?

byubyu

2:00pm

Because the offense gets to pick when to snap the ball.

momowagon

2:06pm

If the D doesn't sub "fast enough" they could be penalized for too many men

VACOUGFAN

1:51pm

Offense waits until 15 seconds left, then sprints one package on and another off

reddead

2:21pm

I would make the offense start sub prior to 25 sec on the clock. Ref holds snap

JAGA97

1:41pm

It's fixed with 3 words. No slow jog. That's it. No slow jogging.

rcbyufan

1:49pm

Both players have to be moving at the same time. No more jogging to the center

VACOUGFAN

1:52pm

Too subjective. There's gotta be a bright line rule.

momowagon

1:54pm

all subs done by 5 seconds left on play clock.

VACOUGFAN

2:12pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad