It is best for the Big XII, but not for BYU

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 11, 2024
12:40:17pm

Huge Manatee Intervention Needed

It is best for the Big XII, but not for BYU

Report problem with this ad

Huge Manatee

Previous username: Bronoc
Bio page: Huge Manatee
Joined: Mar 14, 2011
Last login: Nov 21, 2024
Total posts: 54,048 (5,712 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I like Drake Toll, but I don't like what he seems to suggest: that it is best for the conference if BYU is undefeated

Knight-who-says-ni Walk-on

Nov 11, 12:38pm

He is not wrong. Not sure what you don't agree with.

kimdaddy35

Nov 11, 12:39pm

He is wrong. Big 12 isn’t getting two teams.

BYU '80

Nov 11, 12:41pm

This is correct.

tkh9

Nov 11, 12:41pm

You are wrong, 12-1 BYU who loses in the CCG will be in.

kimdaddy35

Nov 11, 12:42pm

They’re not going to pick a 2-loss team who didn’t even make their CCG over BYU

Odysseus

Nov 11, 12:43pm

Then you’re not paying attention.

tkh9

Nov 11, 12:46pm

Hope I am wrong but I think this is correct

yahtzee

Nov 11, 12:47pm

You’re overly paranoid. ACC and Big XII aren’t viewed as the same as SEC, sure.

Odysseus

Nov 11, 12:49pm

Then make sense of the rankings.

tkh9

Nov 11, 12:58pm

One loss hurts you more when (1) you’ve played 8 games instead of 12 and (2) it

Odysseus

Nov 11, 1:09pm

We agree on this point, but the problem is that they’re choosing subjectively

tkh9

Nov 11, 1:33pm

You are talking about committee rankings for this week like they have already happened.

kimdaddy35

Nov 11, 1:15pm

I don’t think two teams get in due to bias. We already see it

BYU '80

Nov 11, 12:39pm

Yep. I was under the impression the committee already implied B12 gets one bid.

Yucatan

Nov 11, 12:41pm

It is best for the Big XII, but not for BYU

Nov 11, 12:40pm

I don't need to listen to his pod, but I doubt he's suggesting that BYU should

Tricky

Nov 11, 12:42pm

He didn't suggest BYU lose on purpose but seemed to indicate who he would be cheering for if it went between BYU and CO.

Knight-who-says-ni

Nov 11, 12:43pm

Not a big deal to me. Even though he's been a BYU stan for more clicks, I don't

Tricky

Nov 11, 12:58pm

Unless we get a home playoff game, then I’ll allow it

Odysseus

Nov 11, 12:44pm

I don't think 2 big 12 teams make the playoff in any scenario

acougfan

Nov 11, 12:40pm

Disagree - if BYU is #5 or 6 and undefeated going into the CCG, they will get in

Nov 11, 12:41pm

Look at the bias against byu already. Ain’t happening. They will choose a three

BYU '80

Nov 11, 12:42pm

It could happen, but it would be unprecedented

Nov 11, 12:43pm

How many 2 loss teams was BYU ranked behind?

kimdaddy35

Nov 11, 12:44pm

There were people who were convinced we’d be ranked #13 in the first CFP ranking

Odysseus

Nov 11, 12:46pm

If BYU is 12-1 they are in. The committee will give them a really tough game, but they will be in.

kimdaddy35

Nov 11, 12:41pm

Yep. Win win win. No losses. Period.

whirl

Nov 11, 12:41pm

What's best for the conference is for BYU to run the table.

BlueFever

Nov 11, 12:41pm

Things that are best for a conference often aren't best for an individual team

BackPacker

Nov 11, 12:41pm

For the sake of the B12, he’s not wrong. Only way they get 2 teams in.

Boring

Nov 11, 12:42pm

One team left.

Archaea

Nov 11, 12:43pm

Media loves Colorado. So if we lose to them in CCG, I think we both get in

4thand19

Nov 11, 12:45pm

He's not wrong that it's the only possibility of getting 2 teams in. I'm not

fattycoug

Nov 11, 1:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad