He made the the right decision for himself. Two Rose bowls, 2x all-Pac 12, 34 career starts (would've been more if not for injuries), played multiple years in one of the best defenses in the country, got to play a year with older brother Gabe, playing now with cousins Logan and Spencer Fano. Take off the blue goggles, and you will see that playing under Scalley's system was always gonna be better than Tuiaki's. Now if Hill had been the coach back then, then your point would have more validity.