Gotta love rules that are written such that they need "interpretation"

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 1, 2024
2:33:26pm

Greg4BYU All-American

Gotta love rules that are written such that they need "interpretation"

Report problem with this ad

Greg4BYU

Bio page: Greg4BYU
Joined: Jan 14, 2003
Last login: Nov 1, 2024
Total posts: 1,638 (27 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Detailed tiebreaker analysis between BYU, ISU, KSU, and Colorado

zuko

1:38pm

If KS loses 1 OR if ISU and CO both lose 1 b4 Farmageddon then we're in @ 11-1

Greg4BYU

1:43pm

11-1 BYU only needs KSU to lose one more to get in for sure. But if KSU wins out

zuko

1:46pm

OK. I edited my post

Greg4BYU

1:54pm

I think you mean if BYU is 11-1, not 11-0. Great work.

durandal

1:49pm

Thanks, fixed

zuko

1:52pm

Interesting, if KSU loses this week our odds shoot up, but our resume gets worse

BYUCLA

1:53pm

This is why I'm rooting for KState against the Coogs.

2:05pm

I would argue our chances are better of winning the CCG than being picked as an

2:20pm

You've got something wrong there. We are guaranteed a spot if our 1 loss is ASU

BYUFootballisBack

2:20pm

And if Colorado wins out and ISU and KSU are 11-1 we can lose to Houston

BYUFootballisBack

2:20pm

Issues with your 11-1 isu/ksu and colorado 9-3 as well, we are in if we lose

BYUFootballisBack

2:25pm

I agree. If our 1 loss is to ASU we are in. KSU wins the 3-way tiebreaker on

RGGeemer

2:26pm

Also issues with the 10-2 isu 10-2 colorado 11-1 ksu one, we are in if our loss

BYUFootballisBack

2:28pm

Hmm, let me investigate this

zuko

2:30pm

The 3 way tiebreaker restarts once a team is picked, so once Kansas State gets

BYUFootballisBack

2:39pm

Interesting, I've been interpreting the tiebreaker procedures differently

zuko

2:57pm

This is what the Big12 doc says, doesn't seem like its ambiguous, but maybe it

BYUFootballisBack

2:59pm

Part of what makes me think we are guaranteed a spot with only 1 loss is the

BYUFootballisBack

3:08pm

Yep. It starts over.

RGGeemer

3:30pm

We are in 100% at 11-1 IF the conference interpretation of the tiebreaker rules

RGGeemer

2:20pm

Gotta love rules that are written such that they need "interpretation"

Greg4BYU

2:33pm

We need divisions.

RGGeemer

2:34pm

Except that opens the door for 1 WEAK division and 1 STRONG one

Greg4BYU

2:38pm

So? Better than going undefeated and maybe missing your CCG (SMU this year)

RGGeemer

2:45pm

In that strong division, the two best teams will play each other and the winner

RGGeemer

2:46pm

It's not a concern to me in the new 12 team playoff. I could see it with 4. Not

RGGeemer

2:47pm

Alright, I fixed the tables to use the same tiebreaker rules as this website

zuko

3:28pm

Looks more like what I expected.

RGGeemer

3:33pm

I have decided that he is interpreting it wrong 🙂 1 loss and we are 100% in CCG

BYUFootballisBack

3:37pm

I hope so!!

RGGeemer

3:43pm

In summary

UnoDoctor

4:52pm

If we lose 0 or 1 games we are in incredible shape

BYUFootballisBack

5:24pm

We really needed UCF to beat ISU and KU to beat K State. Oh well.

Captain Rex

6:29pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad