I'd put McMahon, Detmer, Collie, Jamaal, and TA on offense. Van Noy, Buck, Jorgensen, Dewey, and Rob Morris on
defense. Lee Johnson, Vai, and Dye on STs.
Taysom and Young just miss out Neither had the most passing yds but Taysom had over 3000 yds rushing and Young over 1000 yds too. Pitta and Unga just miss out too.
Just my opinion on some of my favorites. I tried to only use their BYU playing years.