I am thinking further back- for instance, 2001-2004

Jul 23, 2024
3:46:16pm

nova_coug_fan Political Junky

Just in that span, we had Brandon Doman, Bret Engemann, Matt Berry, and Ben Olson, all of whom were four-star (or five star) level QBs.

Report problem with this ad

nova_coug_fan

Bio page: nova_coug_fan
Joined: Jan 5, 2013
Last login: Nov 14, 2024
Total posts: 2,231 (4 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The last time BYU signed a four-star level QB out of HS was 2012- Tanner Mangum

nova_coug_fan

Jul 23, 2:43pm

What about Jacob Conover?

BYU Fan

Jul 23, 2:45pm

247 only gave him an 84 rating

nova_coug_fan

Jul 23, 2:47pm

It looks like ESPN had him listed with an 84 rating and a 4-star

BYU Fan

Jul 23, 2:51pm

He was an 86 with 247. He was listed as an 84 transfer.

kimdaddy35

Jul 23, 2:53pm

You're looking at his xfer rating, not his HS rating

stansburycoug

Jul 23, 2:57pm

86 was his 247 rating, but his 247 Composite was .9006 which is 4-star.

jreid191

Jul 23, 3:22pm

Not sure I call it "lucky" signing two back to back qbs that vastly

cougarfann888

Jul 23, 2:52pm

Then whoever the QB whisperer was that found Hall and Wilson is gone

BYU Fan

Jul 23, 2:53pm

Bronco's staff Hall, Wilson was all Grimes. There is no common denominator

stansburycoug

Jul 23, 3:05pm

ZW has been mediocre to bad against good competition his entire career.

CallSign

Jul 23, 11:27pm

Wilson and Hall were both better than their ratings. But Baylor Romney is a good

kimdaddy35

Jul 23, 2:56pm

I disagree with your statement that BYU routinely signed high-level QB's out of

cougarfan84

Jul 23, 3:42pm

I am thinking further back- for instance, 2001-2004

nova_coug_fan

Jul 23, 3:46pm

Brandon wasn't a 4 star, however Jason Munns was

stansburycoug

Jul 23, 3:49pm

And not only is it a crapshoot, many times one service will have a QB as a

cougarfan84

Jul 23, 4:15pm

Yes, it is undoubtedly better today

nova_coug_fan

Jul 23, 4:20pm

Brandon Doman was definitely not a 4-star QB. Engemann was class of 96. No clue

cougarfan84

Jul 23, 4:04pm

You sure about Doman?

nova_coug_fan

Jul 23, 4:20pm

He was a heck of a HS QB - in a system that ran the triple option and he wasn't

cougarfan84

Jul 23, 10:30pm

We have always developed good QBs over time.

BigHouse Coug

Jul 23, 4:41pm

Wilson, Hall and Conover were all top 1000 recruits (by composite)

krindorr

Jul 23, 5:39pm

Top 1000 is a pretty low bar.

kimdaddy35

Jul 23, 8:20pm

The likely hood of a 4-5 star QB staying and not playing within 2 years is

bookofdaniel

Jul 23, 7:08pm

We need a real qb coach

crm48

Jul 23, 8:52pm

It's about the QBs. Here's a list of seasons (2000 and beyond) where a not top-1000 QB had heavy usage

Posting on CougarBoard