It's the coach's job to get the right fit. Shaylee was never returning. Her goal was a championship which was never going to happen at BYU. Besides that, she graduated and Juddy left. Nani was injured, then engaged and ultimately her focus turned away from basketball to Kingsley. By the time, she could come back, Amari took her place and rightfully so. Her two no-shows are better off where they are. They made no impact on their teams last year. One, had zero stats. Davenport was a great get. Woolston, Whiting and Mata are great gets. Gibb will take Woolston's place. The rest of the transfers/freshmen to be, I can't speak about.
Although I have questioned some of her decisions, which is my right, I think she has done a good job in spite of injuries and other sundry happenings. Just my opinion, as you have yours.