Sep 27, 2022
11:00:54am
11:00:54am
I’m realizing it is so hard to compare QBs and RBs at BYU across generations
I honestly can’t make up my mind if Allgeier, Staley, or Jamaal is the best.
At QB, I can say that Max Hall’s career was significantly more impressive than Beck’s, but Beck was a better QB his senior year. I could say Zach may have had the most complete skill set but only showed it consistently in one season against a weaker schedule with no P5 teams. He also didn’t have the benefit of a senior year. I could say Jaren has the best overall win resume, has a complete skill set, and he makes very few mistakes, but he hasn’t played a full season at BYU and he has had excellent receivers.
It’s also fair to say a great college QB like Detmer can be a poor fit for the NFL and we’ll see what Jaren can do vs Zach depending on a number of factors.
There are so many arguments to be made with Beck, Max Hall, Zach, and Jaren Hall that my head spins.
At QB, I can say that Max Hall’s career was significantly more impressive than Beck’s, but Beck was a better QB his senior year. I could say Zach may have had the most complete skill set but only showed it consistently in one season against a weaker schedule with no P5 teams. He also didn’t have the benefit of a senior year. I could say Jaren has the best overall win resume, has a complete skill set, and he makes very few mistakes, but he hasn’t played a full season at BYU and he has had excellent receivers.
It’s also fair to say a great college QB like Detmer can be a poor fit for the NFL and we’ll see what Jaren can do vs Zach depending on a number of factors.
There are so many arguments to be made with Beck, Max Hall, Zach, and Jaren Hall that my head spins.
- Bio page
- D.T. Survivor
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2017
- Last login
- Dec 25, 2024
- Total posts
- 11,117 (26 FO)
Messages
Time
9/27/22 10:12am
9/27/22 2:11pm
9/27/22 2:11pm
9/27/22 10:19am
i still don't have the confidence in him that I had with Wilson, Max, Beck (Sr. yr) or Sark. By the end of the year
9/27/22 10:30am
9/27/22 6:16pm
9/27/22 10:32am
9/27/22 10:56am
9/27/22 4:27pm
9/27/22 11:00am
9/27/22 11:07am
9/27/22 11:08am
9/27/22 11:08am
9/27/22 2:12pm
I wouldnt compare Hall to Detmer, I think he is a better, more athletic version of Senior Year John Beck.
9/27/22 11:53am
9/27/22 12:22pm
Of course it’s debatable. We’re here debating it. I’m not saying Jaren isn’t great or even that his stats aren’t better.
9/27/22 12:50pm
I mean, you can make fun of it, but literally anyone who evaluates players professionally can see the difference between
9/27/22 1:24pm
Sound good, bro. No one is saying they are the same. In case you missed the OP he was comparing Hall to Detmer.
9/27/22 4:00pm
I didn’t make an appeal to authority. I just explained where I’ve watched them and specifically said you *don’t* have
9/27/22 5:08pm
I would bet that Jaren Hall gets drafted similar to where Beck was drafted, but that he will have a better career.
9/27/22 6:25pm
9/27/22 2:13pm
9/27/22 1:16pm
9/27/22 1:27pm
9/27/22 1:35pm
9/27/22 2:10pm
9/27/22 2:14pm
9/27/22 2:16pm
9/27/22 4:29pm
9/27/22 5:39pm