If you are looking at longevity stats then certainly Hall at 8 is way too low. He started 3 years which basically

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Aug 11, 2022
4:39:03pm

kimdaddy35 Future Lions Scout

If you are looking at longevity stats then certainly Hall at 8 is way too low. He started 3 years which basically

nobody else other than Detmer has done. He also had some good teams. I certainly can see the argument. But for me the play in big games and the efficiency ratings for Sarkisian trump the longevity stats for Hall. I would guess most would agree with you though.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Nov 27, 2024
Total posts: 51,500 (1,542 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A deep dive into the greatest players of all-time at BYU. Let's start with QB.

kimdaddy35 Future Lions Scout

8/11/22 3:51pm

7 O's, that has to be my all time best.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 3:57pm

Thumbs up on putting your opinion out there. Not everybody has to agree. That

rcbyufan

8/11/22 3:58pm

I'm not sure anyone will 100% agree with my opinion which is OK. I did a fair amount of research into the stats and

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:00pm

I don't know what 'greatest' means in these kind of conversations

Avery

8/11/22 4:03pm

That is the thing. It is a combination of many things including, even to a lesser extent NFL history.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:07pm

I think you have Sheide too low. Dude started the whole thing.

Peter Venkman

8/11/22 4:05pm

That is fair, my rebuttal would be that yes he started it (well really LaVell, but he was the first QB) but others

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:09pm

If Lavell had a schlub QB for 73/74 he probably would've been fired

Peter Venkman

8/11/22 5:00pm

Riley Nelson shouldn’t even be sniffing this list.

kotacoug

8/11/22 4:10pm

I have positive memories of Nelson while I know many of you don't, that is where I cut the list off at.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:14pm

He’s so far below the others just leave him off.

kotacoug

8/11/22 5:30pm

Who would you swap Nelson with?

8/11/22 4:29pm

Jaren Hall

8/11/22 4:49pm

Jaren Hall would already be higher than Nelson as I said, but I am leaving him off my list until his

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:52pm

I skimmed and missed it. Thanks for compiling it.

8/11/22 5:10pm

Not quite eligible from how the OP is doing this.

8/11/22 5:03pm

Your list is pretty close to mine. 4-8 is the hardest to sort out.

Coop

8/11/22 4:27pm

It is very hard. You could make an argument for any of them to be higher or lower.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:36pm

Good stuff. I do think Sark is high on this list

UVCoug

8/11/22 4:31pm

If you are looking at longevity stats then certainly Hall at 8 is way too low. He started 3 years which basically

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:39pm

Walsh is too high. He was the biggest weakness of the very good 94 team, drunk

88Coug

8/11/22 5:04pm

Detmer and Bosco

Y05

12/30/22 4:25pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad