Where the crap did all that money go?

May 3, 2016
9:15:55am

Yvin Starter

He had $50,000, a car, and you claim also scholarships and working. What on earth is he doing with all that money that he thinks he actually needs or deserves financial aid?! Good crap, BYU is not that expensive. He should be sailing through BYU with that kind of help. Ridiculous.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on May 3, 2016 at 9:15:55am

Message modified by Yvin on May 3, 2016 at 9:16:57am

Report problem with this ad

Yvin

Previous username: nell
Bio page: Yvin
Joined: Sep 8, 2011
Last login: Oct 9, 2019
Total posts: 1,312 (235 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Federal Financial Aid is a rigged game

Jersey hunter All-American

5/2/16 11:39pm

Tell him to get married.

rggee

5/2/16 11:44pm

It increased my motivation to get married when my married colleagues would be

Sandstone Cougar

5/3/16 12:27am

I don't have to say it - he's working on it.

Jersey hunter

5/3/16 9:21am

I don't know if I should thumbs up or down. The system does in fact suck

kotacoug

5/2/16 11:44pm

The system is punishing the kid who works hard and is self reliant. What happened to logic!

Oaktown12

5/2/16 11:46pm

Someone has to pay for all those losers out there

kotacoug

5/2/16 11:47pm

rules are weird, but not sure why anyone thinks the rules are different for different people

Deleted

5/2/16 11:49pm

because liberals base everything off of race, ethnicity, class, gender,

ds7

5/3/16 6:45pm

Don't worry, when you succeed in life, have a good career or own a business

Saxa

5/3/16 5:21am

Race doesn't matter is any of those scenarios. If your family was black or

RC Vikings

5/2/16 11:50pm

Not true. There are such things known as "affirmative action." My best

Cougarfan777

5/2/16 11:56pm

this topic has nothing to do with schollies.

Deleted

5/2/16 11:58pm

He wasn't talking about scholarships, he was talking about government financial

RC Vikings

5/2/16 11:59pm

Yes, but when that fails, he has less access to other programs then do

Cougarfan777

5/3/16 12:06am

It sounds like he was lucky enough to be born into a family with some assets.

RC Vikings

5/3/16 12:11am

So was my friend, yet he never had to even apply for financial aid, he took

Cougarfan777

5/3/16 12:24am

American Indian would change everything.

JAGA97

5/2/16 11:56pm

Free school is the least they can get for genocide of their people. Good heavens

spugeddy24

5/3/16 9:03am

Good grief ... Drama queenish remark

kotacoug

5/3/16 11:21pm

Pretty accurate remark

kimchicoug

5/3/16 11:39pm

You have no idea - go visit a Rez and say that again.

Brass Monkey

5/4/16 12:00am

I've freaking lived by a Rez my whole life

kotacoug

5/4/16 8:27am

Then you're ignorant

Brass Monkey

5/4/16 9:54am

just ask elizabeth warren...

ds7

5/3/16 6:47pm

This is wildly inaccurate and a racist stereotype.

Brass Monkey

5/3/16 7:26pm

Of course it does. Many more resources available to minorities

kotacoug

5/2/16 11:58pm

not in FAFSA

Deleted

5/2/16 11:59pm

True but who needs Fafsa if you have scholarships, grants and other aid availabl

kotacoug

5/3/16 12:00am

It's shocking how often we hear that silliness when arguing for the other side.

Belboz

5/3/16 8:50am

It is true - that's why they have you state your race and ethnicity on the application

Jersey hunter

5/3/16 9:23am

The message has been clear for several years now to blue collar America. Keep

Cougarfan777

5/2/16 11:53pm

I had a Roomate who had his parent essentially dis own him after being baptized

cougarfann888

5/2/16 11:53pm

In a situation like that he should have applied to be emancipated...

BYUFam1

5/3/16 6:02am

Yes but the problem is you have to do it before you are 18

cougarfann888

5/3/16 9:19am

Has it changed recently? I never had to put my parents info in ? They are pretty

Dillinger

5/2/16 11:54pm

You have to if single and under 26.

rggee

5/2/16 11:55pm

If you were married over 25 or in grad school then you don't need to otherwise

cougarfann888

5/2/16 11:55pm

Hmmm, I graduated when I was 26 and got married the same year.

Dillinger

5/2/16 11:58pm

It was required in 2009 for sure. Maybe you just stole from taxpayers

rggee

5/3/16 12:02am

There's a good chance.

Dillinger

5/3/16 12:07am

Not true.

BigGulps

5/3/16 6:18am

It is true. Here's a link

cougarfann888

5/3/16 9:23am

Recently? That's about how it was 20 years ago.

BW84

5/3/16 12:01am

I graduated 6 years ago.

Dillinger

5/3/16 12:07am

When I went from 2004 to 2007 the age cutoff was 23 for parents assets.

BNcoug

5/3/16 3:27pm

It makes sense to me that financial aid should be for those who don't

MrF

5/3/16 12:27am

Why should parents be financially obligated to pay for an adult child's

SierraCoug

5/3/16 12:50am

Why should the taxpayers?

Mississippi

5/3/16 12:58am

Here's the scenario as it currently exists.

SierraCoug

5/3/16 1:07am

You should probably just vote for Bernie...

Mississippi

5/3/16 1:21am

no one should get pell grants get student loans, the only exception is I might

cougarfann888

5/3/16 1:33am

I'm unsure of what your point is, do you want the government to pay for

MrF

5/3/16 1:23am

I'd prefer nobody gets it, but the system is broken when a student is

SierraCoug

5/3/16 1:27am

Seriously, what if the parents were billionaires?

Mississippi

5/3/16 1:32am

Did you miss the part where I said I'd prefer nobody got it?

SierraCoug

5/3/16 1:43am

The fact that many do receive it raises demand and thus increases the cost for

AF Cougar

5/3/16 6:26am

As the system is now, there needs to be a cut off for when students

MrF

5/3/16 1:39am

My biggest problem is why does what is in your retirement 401K matter to FAFSA?

BYUFam1

5/3/16 5:57am

It zzz

byukarl

5/3/16 7:30am

Ummmm, you serious?

Cougarealist

5/3/16 6:26am

He had $6,000 of income?

JAGA97

5/3/16 12:30am

Illegal immigrants don't get pell grants, lies like this make rational debate

Cabadapeste

5/3/16 2:39am

This is true

BYUFam1

5/3/16 5:46am

How long ago was this? Maybe I can help. BM me the details.

byuTX

5/3/16 6:51am

Kind of an odd thumbs down Jersey hunter...care to expound on why?

BYUFam1

5/3/16 10:42am

Post of the day because so few people know this. It's so frustrating to

TayPower

5/3/16 10:37am

this isn't new

bald man

5/3/16 2:44am

Why does everyone always want handouts from the government?

Supercoug

5/3/16 4:29am

You conveniently forget the purpose for which Federal Financial Aid is offered:

Six Foot Seven

5/3/16 4:47am

<< Deleted >>

TheHop

5/3/16 5:59am

RE: You conveniently forget the purpose for which Federal Financial Aid is

rmreitz

5/3/16 1:36pm

Why Should the Govt. Help Him and Not You?

Uncle Bluto

5/3/16 5:01am

You should be able to put him back in your health insurance. I've had my

NewMexiCoug

5/3/16 5:56am

And I believe new laws would let you keep a child on your insurance even if

BYUFam1

5/3/16 6:08am

Illegal immigrants don't get aid or grants from FAFSA or any other federal source As far as your son goes, it does

byuTX

5/3/16 6:03am

Medicare is for 62+. Medicaid is for the poor.

claw

5/3/16 6:09am

Thanks. Fixed

byuTX

5/3/16 6:43am

So you feel like the government should be giving him

Cougarealist

5/3/16 6:25am

Agreed. Kids should try to make it on own as much as possible but when need help

runnincoug

5/3/16 6:41am

I'm against handouts*

bluebloodedcoug

5/3/16 6:44am

Since parental support is pretty untraceable, I think it's appropriate to

JONBOY

5/3/16 6:50am

A better strategy would be for you to claim

wjman11

5/3/16 7:08am

If he's making $6,000, he's not paying any federal income tax to speak of.

russkiejedi

5/3/16 7:16am

The church asks families to look to family for help first before going to the

russkiejedi

5/3/16 7:11am

That's the fallacy here. Teaching "self reliance" while asking for govt. bailout

runnincoug

5/3/16 7:17am

Also, was he not one of your kids who started college with $50K in a 529 plan?

russkiejedi

5/3/16 7:20am

Wow, what happened in the last two weeks? Did the market crash and I missed it??

Six Foot Seven

5/3/16 7:25am

Looks like this son took that money and went to Wendover or something

BYUheaven

5/3/16 7:50am

Apparently something like that:

russkiejedi

5/3/16 8:26am

Uh oh

shimmy

5/3/16 7:56am

RE: Also, was he not one of your kids who started college with $50K in a 529

WDaddy

5/3/16 7:56am

RE: Also, was he not one of your kids who started college with $50K in a 529

kimchicoug

5/3/16 8:02am

tempted to thumbs down for using an Aggie clip in a positive way....very tempted

BYUheaven

5/3/16 8:04am

RE: Also, was he not one of your kids who started college with $50K in a 529

WDaddy

5/3/16 8:14am

RE: Also, was he not one of your kids who started college with $50K in a 529

Cabadapeste

5/3/16 8:25am

His post was just trying to brag about himself selling whole life insurance

RdF3

5/3/16 8:55am

Yes and that is where he will have to make up the difference, one of the benefits of that strategy is those

Jersey hunter

5/3/16 8:57am

So your son has a silver spoon, and you complain he doesn't get the free spork.

Fatalplacebo

5/3/16 9:03am

Just keep digging...

Defenestrator

5/3/16 9:09am

This is really great. Please, continue

Linescratcher

5/3/16 9:14am

So in essence you are complaining about no free lunch when your kid has

Big Daddy D

5/3/16 9:14am

So he does have the 50k, then why did you say he pays for school himself?

BYUheaven

5/3/16 9:15am

The money is there if he needs it - he hasn't touched a penny

Jersey hunter

5/3/16 9:25am

so he wants tax payers to pay instead of using his own money

Deleted

5/3/16 9:27am

Wow, you REALLY don't get it. 529 accounts are tax advantaged to HELP w/ school

runnincoug

5/3/16 9:29am

So it sounds like he needs it.

RalphWiggam

5/3/16 9:57am

8 years of BYU tuition? That's another huge red flag. And to your other point

runnincoug

5/3/16 10:00am

Sorry...post wasn't meant for you. I agree w/ you completely.

RalphWiggam

5/3/16 10:07am

ha! Yeah, and threads like this get crazy.

runnincoug

5/3/16 10:13am

THE SYSTEM IS RIGGED!

DapperDan

5/3/16 9:31am

That is great! Seems like you son is learning good saving habits and getting

BYUheaven

5/3/16 9:33am

If he's going to Uncle Sam for money, I think he's reached the point where he

russkiejedi

5/3/16 9:34am

This is hilarious.

cougfanblue

5/3/16 9:37am

So he wants the govt to pay for his school so he can use said money for a house

Dillinger

5/3/16 9:47am

More precisely, he wants you and I to pay for our kids' AND his kid's education

Rogue Gunner

5/3/16 9:56am

DUDE....put down the shovel, and walk away.......

TheHop

5/3/16 9:47am

Reminds me of Deebo from Friday: "I want to spend Red's money."

WDaddy

5/3/16 9:53am

I had a roommate who would eat our food because he didn't want to sell his stock

BluebloodOR

5/3/16 11:29am

Why you gotta hate on the poor young man for his self-reliance?

russkiejedi

5/3/16 11:30am

Are you being serious right now?

Big Daddy D

5/3/16 11:55am

Where the crap did all that money go?

Yvin

5/3/16 9:15am

Yep. Is a $5500 Pell grant even going to help at this point?

rggee

5/3/16 9:20am

See above. His college savings were not to be touched for college, apparently.

russkiejedi

5/3/16 9:35am

make up the difference...after 50k? uh...byu is like 5k a semester

Deleted

5/3/16 9:20am

$2500 for LDS students

rggee

5/3/16 9:22am

So your problem is that FAFSA was able to get around your best-laid planning to

russkiejedi

5/3/16 9:26am

DOWN WITH EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT! A POX UPON SOUND FISCAL POLICY!

Linescratcher

5/3/16 9:33am

Wow, you still don't get it. If your son needs a handout from the govt. he isn't

runnincoug

5/3/16 9:28am

This is so sad. Your poor son.

The Underminer

5/3/16 10:37am

Someone who is using federal money is not "making it on their own".

Be Y's

5/3/16 12:53pm

Actually 24. You can be eligible for grants at 24 (or marriage yes).

Brass Monkey

5/3/16 5:47pm

Amen.

spugeddy24

5/3/16 9:04am

BOOOOOOOM!!!!!!

TheHop

5/3/16 9:19am

BOOM GOES THE DYNAMITE!

CDV

5/3/16 11:59am

spot on

couldge

5/3/16 1:42pm

The government took over student loans remember.

BigGulps

5/3/16 7:28am

This was meant for the church reliance poster above.

BigGulps

5/3/16 7:30am

Already been said but I'll repeat, you being white is irrelevant.

Rogue Gunner

5/3/16 7:31am

Maybe you should just help your son with school

SJS

5/3/16 7:48am

Why do you not claim your son as a dependent?

Clark Addison

5/3/16 7:55am

Best thing was getting married. Pell Grants paid for my wife and I's tuition

dallasbyu

5/3/16 8:38am

What an embarrassing post.

spugeddy24

5/3/16 9:14am

So every student is (should be) entitled to a pell grant?

stonewallperry

5/3/16 9:56am

Lol.

byubyu

5/3/16 11:47am

As a foreign student, immigrants don't just automatically get federal aid.

THE KlD

5/3/16 12:19pm

If you don't want to pay for your son's education, why not offer him a loan similar to what

LiveCoug

5/3/16 12:54pm

He makes $6000 a year? Is he a fry cook?

Posting on CougarBoard