BYU opponents that they have played: 34-38 (8 games)
Wins over 2 ranked opponents (SMU, Kansas St)
Best OOC win: #13 SMU
Top 2 Big 12 wins: Kansas St (7-2), Baylor (5-4)

Miami opponents that they have played: 38-38 (9 games)
No wins over ranked opponents
Best OOC win: Florida
Top 2 ACC wins: Duke (6-3), Louisville (6-3)

If you took Miami and BYUs name off both of these and had to guess which one has had the better season you would choose BYU.