May 7, 2024
1:38:08pm
1:38:08pm
I am genuinely curious. What are compelling reasons why you feel confident in
Kalani as a HC moving forward?
What evidence do you point to that makes you feel confident that Kalani is the coach that can lead us to a high level of success?
***How I define high level of success at BYU is a consistent top 30ish program. Top half of the P4. 10 year example span might be: 1x top 10 season (10+ wins), 2 top 25 seasons (8-9 wins), 4 unranked but solid teams (6-8 wins), 2 mediocre years (4-5 wins), and 1 awful season (4 wins or less).
Expectations higher than that are very delusional IMO.
In Kalani's 8 seasons (7 of which at the non-P5 level) we've seen 1 borderline top 10 team in 2020 (semi-discredited due to weak COVID schedule), 1 top 25 season in 2021, 2 unranked but solid seasons in 2016 and 2022, 3 mediocre seasons in 2018, 2019, and 2023, and 1 awful year in 2017. Judging off of my criteria, Kalani underperformed. This is concerning given these years were at a non P5 level.
What evidence do you point to that makes you feel confident that Kalani is the coach that can lead us to a high level of success?
***How I define high level of success at BYU is a consistent top 30ish program. Top half of the P4. 10 year example span might be: 1x top 10 season (10+ wins), 2 top 25 seasons (8-9 wins), 4 unranked but solid teams (6-8 wins), 2 mediocre years (4-5 wins), and 1 awful season (4 wins or less).
Expectations higher than that are very delusional IMO.
In Kalani's 8 seasons (7 of which at the non-P5 level) we've seen 1 borderline top 10 team in 2020 (semi-discredited due to weak COVID schedule), 1 top 25 season in 2021, 2 unranked but solid seasons in 2016 and 2022, 3 mediocre seasons in 2018, 2019, and 2023, and 1 awful year in 2017. Judging off of my criteria, Kalani underperformed. This is concerning given these years were at a non P5 level.
- Previous username
- _Dakoko
- Bio page
- TheMediator
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2019
- Last login
- May 19, 2024
- Total posts
- 3,248 (0 FO)
The argument that we shouldn't count the 2020 team for Kalani is frustrating (spidercoug, May 7, 2024 at 2:09pm)
Messages
Time
May 7, 1:42pm
May 7, 4:58pm
May 7, 6:43pm
May 7, 5:29pm
May 7, 5:28pm
May 7, 1:43pm
May 7, 2:02pm
May 7, 3:58pm
May 7, 6:47pm
May 7, 2:16pm
May 7, 2:26pm
May 7, 5:31pm
May 7, 1:58pm
May 7, 1:58pm
May 7, 2:09pm
May 7, 3:28pm
Try to keep in mind that BYU has been at a recruiting disadvantage compared to other P5 teams by being an Indy program.
May 7, 2:22pm
IMO, most of that falls on Lamb & Tuiaki's recruiting. Fortunately, both are gone. Let's see what happens going forward.
May 7, 2:35pm
May 7, 4:34pm
May 7, 5:44pm
May 7, 3:39pm
May 7, 4:10pm
May 7, 5:20pm
May 8, 9:05am
May 7, 7:07pm
May 8, 9:12am