added and subtracted cars and teen drivers with always very reasonable rates. We had a few no fault incidents but no tickets, no wrecks. Still my rates remained consistent. I did a check on progressive at about year 10 but it was more expensive. I also increased my limits for a very small charge because it was required for work mileage reimbursement.

Then, we went to buy a brand new car, dropped one of our teens, and drop one of our full coverage vehicles. Geico jumped 3x. It seemed really high so I shopped around and found something for half of what Geico quoted. The weird thing was I just couldn't find any justifiable reason Geico quoted so much higher.