You could make an argument for six. But you certainly don't need 12.

Report problem with this ad

Jan 2, 2025
8:29:20pm

shoganai All-American

Report problem with this ad

shoganai

Bio page: shoganai
Joined: Jul 15, 2004
Last login: Jan 4, 2025
Total posts: 33,549 (790 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Theoretical CFP bracket based on the FCS playoff format.

shoganai

Jan 2, 7:59pm

Thanks for sharing. Good reminder that it would be terrible.

TCuz

Jan 2, 8:00pm

Reminder that a G6 non champ beat a semifinal team on that semifinal team’s home

CameronG

Jan 2, 8:08pm

I’m afraid of being bored to death watching Marshall and Jacksonville State waste everybody’s time

TCuz

Jan 2, 8:24pm

Don’t watch till the semis then

CameronG

Jan 2, 8:26pm

Yet there you would be... watching. With millions of others.

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:28pm

Nobody would watch this and nobody will cause it will never happen. Cause it’s a terrible idea.

TCuz

Jan 2, 8:32pm

You're probably right. I mean, just imagine if ESPN put all those teams in

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:35pm

Bowls suck. Your format is great. Just the wrong teams.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:39pm

Ohio vs Jacksonville State got less than 1m viewers this bowl season. You said “millions.”

TCuz

Jan 2, 8:39pm

This is a fantastic post. Maybe the most on-brand one you've ever made.

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:41pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:42pm

It would be better if they did play each other. At least it would be a good game

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:49pm

They don’t. But it shows that nobody wants to watch these guys play football

TCuz

Jan 2, 8:57pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:59pm

There are functional differences between football and basketball. You can play 100 basketball games a year

TCuz

Jan 2, 9:04pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:06pm

Do you watch the FCS playoffs?

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 9:27pm

I do, there are a lot of fun games

CameronG

Jan 2, 9:28pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:34pm

Yep, you have to be obtuse to conflate the 2.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:07pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:08pm

Who did i call a name?

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:18pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:20pm

"Obtuse" is an adjective, a description. It is not a name.

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 9:28pm

I used to think your elitist attitude was just a schtick

CameronG

Jan 2, 9:00pm

And I have no idea who you are.

TCuz

Jan 2, 9:05pm

Perfectly on brand response from you, you think you’re better than everyone else

CameronG

Jan 2, 9:07pm

You aren’t by chance a UofU professor with pac12 consulting experience are you?

kcca

Jan 2, 9:12pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:35pm

TCuz hates March Madness, too many teams for his liking

CameronG

Jan 2, 8:56pm

Love all the home games. Fans can't travel to 4 bowl games.

Art Director

Jan 2, 8:00pm

Have to imagine they'll kick the bowl games out of bed eventually and go heavily

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:06pm

Exciting, inclusive, football to be won on the field

CameronG

Jan 2, 8:07pm

That’s a lot of playoff games 😂

Hufflepuff

Jan 2, 8:08pm

Yep. That's the best part, IMO.

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:09pm

It would be awesome.

Groym

Jan 2, 8:10pm

Barf. Give G5 or whatever their own championship.

shimmy

Jan 2, 8:11pm

I mean, there's a plausible chance that's where we're headed, except it will be

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:15pm

Yep. All home games until the finals, but let's have good teams instead of

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:17pm

If we're only interested in teams that have a plausible chance of winning...

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:19pm

You mean a tournament without Notre Dame and Ohio St?

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:25pm

You could make an argument for six. But you certainly don't need 12.

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:29pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:21pm

I don't get what you mean by invitational. Anyone can earn their way into the

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:30pm

Not entirely true. If there are ever multiple undefeated G5s, very good chance

shoganai

Jan 2, 8:33pm

Millions more would watch Colorado-SMU than would watch Jacksonville-SMU.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:53pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:37pm

Untrue. If the worst team in college football this year goes 13-0 and beats 2 P4

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:54pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:56pm

I added to my post the example of Boise St. A loss and no P4 wins. Got in.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 8:58pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:01pm

Better way to say it, in every other college sport conference champs qualify for

CameronG

Jan 2, 9:03pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:05pm

This ignores the fact they're are a lot more playoff spots for every other sport

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:06pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:07pm

The point is you're leaving out quality teams like Colorado and adding garbage.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:09pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:18pm

Huh?

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:20pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:22pm

March Madness is an invitational tournament. They just give an invite to each

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 9:34pm

As chilawcoug said a lot more conferences

CameronG

Jan 2, 9:16pm

Not sure how percentages became a point. You're leaving 14 at large spots

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:23pm

The vast majority of those conferences get only one berth. And there are 68

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 9:30pm

It’s about the same ratio

CameronG

Jan 2, 9:35pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:57pm

What other sport has 130 competitors and a 24 team postseason?

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:00pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:03pm

Yep, that's the point. Not enough spots for 8-4 MAC champs

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:13pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:19pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 8:39pm

Army would be in a the 6th Conference champ in my proposal, Oklahoma would not.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:18pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:21pm

Have a good night man.

Methusaleh22

Jan 2, 9:25pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 9:27pm

Love it. Need a good name like March Madness.

porl thompson

Jan 2, 10:34pm

Except Army played Navy on Dec 14 - can’t play Marshall on the same weekend

CoolB

Jan 2, 10:58pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad