99 Passer Rating. None of those things are bad, I just don't think they belong with the top 4.

That is fewer yards and a lower passer rating than everyone on the list except Mahomes, who has a lower passer rating.


I am just fine putting him at 5, although statistically Goff has been much better this year and his team is much better. I would rather have Herbert than Goff (partially because he is younger). What I am waiting for is for Herbert to make that last jump. I think he will. But it hasn't really happened this year. He has just been good again this year as opposed to great.