Yep - they deserve to be in the playoff but shouldn't be ranked over ASU

Report problem with this ad

Dec 29, 2024
3:11:10pm

BYU Fan All-American

I'd probably have had them as the #12 seed.

Report problem with this ad

BYU Fan

Bio page: BYU Fan
Joined: Mar 7, 2002
Last login: Jan 1, 2025
Total posts: 26,190 (1,181 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Where did the CFP committee screw up the most?

Poseidon

12/29/24 2:12pm

They didn’t based on what the teams had done at the time

byuTX

12/29/24 2:14pm

No, they did... Tenn didn't deserve to be in...

Xenon

12/29/24 2:19pm

Tenn did based on their record. But there are a number of people that share your minority opinion. Fun to debate though

byuTX

12/29/24 2:28pm

I think they got it mostly right except for Boise getting a bye

BYU Fan

12/29/24 2:31pm

Would you have given it to Clemson instead? Army, Jacksonville state or Marshall?

byuTX

12/29/24 2:41pm

If losing to Oregon is amazing, losing to Georgia & S Carolina is even better

BYU Fan

12/29/24 2:46pm

They were not going to give Boise a home game. I actually don't think the big 10

johnnybyu

12/29/24 2:49pm

No need to give them a home game, they aren't a top-20 team

BYU Fan

12/29/24 2:56pm

We will see. Glad they are getting a shot to prove if they are.

johnnybyu

12/29/24 3:02pm

I wish ASU got to play in the Fiesta Bowl vs Penn State

BYU Fan

12/29/24 3:12pm

I agree they aren’t a playoff caliber team but they deserve it under the CFP rules.

byuTX

12/29/24 3:05pm

Yep - they deserve to be in the playoff but shouldn't be ranked over ASU

BYU Fan

12/29/24 3:11pm

B12 didn't get enough and B10 got too many.

Benfica1

12/29/24 4:54pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad