I know it might not be popular, but for me, 2020 is at least on par with this year. This year is awesome and has been so fun, but 2020 was amazing too.
2020 BYU basically saved the cfb season west of the Rockies. It was COVID and the world was crazy buy BYU taking on Navy was a national moment on par with beating Colorado. Having football meant a lot to the country at that time.
So, 2024 was the more impressive season but 2020 was at least as good of a season, for me.