My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 25, 2024
4:43
:37
pm
HimmerFredette
Truly Addicted User
Ya that helps
But Brady had Gronk and Edelman. That’s not nearly as good as Smith and Irvin but someone still needs get them the ball in a catchable spot. Aikman was good but not great. I agree he is a bit overrated but he is still a good QB.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
HimmerFredette
Previous username
JackArchi
Bio page
HimmerFredette
Joined
Feb 16, 2024
Last login
Dec 25, 2024
Total posts
3,456 (5 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Where does Steve Young rank as NFL QBs
Archaea
Dec 25, 3:39pm
Has to be top 50. Maybe top 25
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 3:41pm
Montana?
Archaea
Dec 25, 3:41pm
What about him?
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 3:43pm
Where do rank him?
Archaea
Dec 25, 3:43pm
Around 10
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 3:44pm
He was frustratingly timely and special
Archaea
Dec 25, 3:45pm
Young or montana
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 3:46pm
Montana. I only liked SF when Young played
Archaea
Dec 25, 3:52pm
Well I’m a cowboys fan so I have mixed feelings about that
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 3:54pm
TNT would say #2. But Mahomes is closing
TNT
Dec 25, 3:59pm
Above Peyton? Really?
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:00pm
Yeah. Montana was incredibly clutch. Just like Brady
TNT
Dec 25, 4:01pm
True. I think it is really close between Montana and Manning
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:03pm
Well and there are a bunch TNT never saw play. Bart Starr, Tarkenton, Staubach
TNT
Dec 25, 4:05pm
There are a bunch I never saw play
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:07pm
Aikman is extremely overrated in TNT's book
TNT
Dec 25, 4:09pm
He’s good. I am a cowboys fan so a bit biased
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:10pm
Best O-line in NFL history. Also had Michael Irvin and Emmitt Smith
TNT
Dec 25, 4:13pm
Ya that helps
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:43pm
I saw all of them play.
Archaea
Dec 25, 4:23pm
You ARE young.
Archaea
Dec 25, 4:22pm
Me Or TNT
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:40pm
Both
Archaea
Dec 25, 4:47pm
Must be above Brady, because any legitimate list has Peyton #1.
bluecougar1985
Dec 25, 4:08pm
Young in many ways revolutionized the QB position along with Randell Cunningham, but Young had a better command of the
specsauce
Dec 25, 3:42pm
Ahead of his time, one of the first real dual threat QBs, put up good numbers
ArcticKat
Dec 25, 3:54pm
Top 5
AF Cougar
Dec 25, 3:42pm
Near the bottom.
The Pope
Dec 25, 3:45pm
15-20 years ago, he often made top 10 all-time lists. Probably still top 15-20
STL
Dec 25, 3:47pm
20 years ago he was probably top 5. But there have been a ton of QBs who have
Duke Silver
Dec 25, 3:47pm
Yes, he lost years of production playing behind Montana
AF Cougar
Dec 25, 3:53pm
But I bet Montana taught him a lot. He seems like a great mentor
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 3:58pm
Nope. He hated Steve. This is well documented. They made up a few years ago
TNT
Dec 25, 4:00pm
Oh my bad
HimmerFredette
Dec 25, 4:01pm
Steve Bono and Montana both seemed to have a thing against Young for a time
BYUBandfan
Dec 25, 4:03pm
Bono and Montana both ended up moving to KC
BYUBandfan
Dec 25, 4:04pm
RE: Nope. He hated Steve. This is well documented. They made up a few years ago
BYUBandfan
Dec 25, 4:09pm
Steve is a very different QB from Joe
AF Cougar
Dec 25, 5:05pm
Definitely Top 50. This NFL.com article has him at 15
Revolution
Dec 25, 3:48pm
I would go with Steve over Tom Brady any time.
BYUBandfan
Dec 25, 3:58pm
Oh cmon. That is just a little too blue goggled
TNT
Dec 25, 4:06pm
1994 Steve was incredible
Odysseus
Dec 25, 4:14pm
He was. Brady has six (seven?) NFL rings and was crazy clutch
TNT
Dec 25, 4:15pm
And for the record Steve Young is TNT's favorite QB of all time
TNT
Dec 25, 4:17pm
Yes, Young was great. But 2007 Brady was perfect.
Revolution
Dec 25, 4:27pm
Like Steve, Tom benefited from having good coaches and teammates around him.
BYUBandfan
Dec 25, 4:17pm
If Steve has started our on a good team instead of the LA Express and TB Bucs
BYUBandfan
Dec 25, 4:20pm
Top 10-15, but at his peak I’d say Top 5
Odysseus
Dec 25, 4:03pm
Top 15, IMO. Maybe Top 10. He was really good. Better than Bradshaw for sure.
Japan Coug
Dec 25, 4:48pm
Top 15 for sure.
lightmann
Dec 25, 6:14pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad