So many of the good ones had injury issues. Hinds and Tuifua would have been

Dec 24, 2024
8:34:53am

cougaman Truly Addicted User

great. ah You would have been much better if healthy. Not sure if Holt was just overrated… I’m very hopeful for Swanson though

Report problem with this ad

cougaman

Bio page: cougaman
Joined: Mar 11, 2006
Last login: Dec 24, 2024
Total posts: 73,550 (5,545 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

247's all-time BYU commits list. If this doesn't make you depressed....

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

8:08am

It might. If I could read it.

Brigham

8:09am

RE: It might. If I could read it.

MaximusMeridius

10:51am

BYU didn't have very good luck with its best football commits but

Archaea

8:11am

Since LaVell arrived in 1972 we're a program that lives off of

gopman

11:02am

Top athletes tend to not perform with BYU

Cougz19

8:12am

It’s sad how small that 4* sample size is

CougarCanuck76

8:13am

Here's the next 5 on that list

Indy Coug

8:16am

Yikes again. Bronson was good but that’s it.

Magneto

8:17am

Bronson was great

Cougz19

8:17am

So many of the good ones had injury issues. Hinds and Tuifua would have been

cougaman

8:34am

Would have figured KVN, and Apo would have been up there.

Tuskaloosa Cougar

9:11am

Apo is rated BYU's #7 best recruit ever

AFcoug7

1:29pm

Yikes. All those guys were duds.

Magneto

8:16am

Matt Reynolds? Dude was a stud. Scott Young was fine too.

WP17

10:13am

Hinds was plenty good, but was chronically injured and never had a chance

Threw and Through

1:38pm

Any chance Walt Williams could still be coming along with Eddie Scipio to revolutionize the defensive backfield.

Spiff

8:17am

If. It them, maybe their kids

TADOW

8:23am

I heard Walt’s kid is a senior this year….

BYU Grounds

12:53pm

At least 3 had decent to solid careers. Wow, need to do better going forward.

NorCal_Coug

8:17am

The infamous Walt Williams

crimedog

8:18am

Any chance 247 had some of these guys ranked too high?

Tuskaloosa Cougar

9:09am

My favorite was Walt Williams. Dude could play.

kimdaddy35

9:44am

He was a D2 1st team All-American after leaving JC

Indy Coug

10:36am

So he still has eligibility?

WaffleCheese

1:30pm

Like I said, he could play.

kimdaddy35

3:03pm

Lesson here is don't get to hyped over ANY recruit until they play CFB

SoValleyCOUG

10:24am

Illuminating. 247 is a media company with subscriptions and ads run by journalists w/ fans and journalists as customers

GoodBetterBestBYU

10:32am

Now do the top transfers to BYU. This would be a much more interesting list

SnickSnack

11:31am

I'd look up schools who consistently have recruiting classes that high but then

Ripliancum

11:37am

Withing 6 years we'll have a signing class that matches this all time list.

Ripliancum

2:11pm

Hopefully much sooner than 6 years.

SnickSnack

4:44pm

I heard Walt Williams is on his way to campus

Your Royal Blueness

2:24pm

Mangum would’ve been amazing absent mental health issues.

Posting on CougarBoard