That could work, but only if you can effectively eliminate "conference strength" bias. Which is near impossible.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 16, 2024
9:00:54am

unctoothman To extract or not to extract..

That could work, but only if you can effectively eliminate "conference strength" bias. Which is near impossible.

Report problem with this ad

unctoothman

Bio page: unctoothman
Joined: Mar 15, 2006
Last login: Jan 6, 2025
Total posts: 72,537 (41,402 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

One issue with the current setup is the easy path Penn St and Indiana had.

WJCougar

12/14/24 6:57am

They have the benefit of Big10 brand bias, so that hardly matters for them

thewaterboy

12/14/24 6:58am

Seems like they will be automatically in every year

WJCougar

12/14/24 6:59am

Some CBers want teams with even easier cakewalk schedules in the CFP over these teams with harder schedules

byuTX

12/14/24 6:59am

Who has easier schedules than these two?

WJCougar

12/14/24 7:02am

All of the G5 conference champions that got left out.

russkiejedi

12/14/24 7:07am

And *one champ that got a bye (deserving under the current rules) *fixed it

byuTX

12/14/24 7:14am

still gotta win all the games against the cakewalk schedule though, which

FieroCoug

12/14/24 7:07am

RE: still gotta win all the games against the cakewalk schedule though, which

WJCougar

12/14/24 7:13am

if it was easy, everyone would do it. instead, it’s quite the opposite.

FieroCoug

12/15/24 9:30pm

This is the same logic used by those who think Bama should’ve gotten SMU’s spot.

garyfan

12/14/24 7:24am

This just means SMU and ND get the equivalent of a 1st round bye

novacoug1

12/14/24 7:36am

Penn St. had a stronger SOS (according to Sagarin) than most of the teams who

cwilke1

12/14/24 7:50am

It's already been discussed by Ross Dellinger. They may keep the same criteria

Schrodizzy

12/14/24 8:31am

That would be dumb. If you get rid of byes for conf champs then CCGs become

rainorsnow

12/14/24 9:00am

Getting in the CFP isn't meaningless

byuTX

12/14/24 9:54am

SEC and B1G CCGs will have a lot less meaning.

rainorsnow

12/14/24 10:02am

Maybe some years. But even just for seeding it'll be plenty meaningful

byuTX

12/14/24 10:08am

Keep the byes, remove the seeding. Based on the CFP rankings this year

Doogal McCougar

12/14/24 9:50am

This basically is what is being proposed in addition to going to 14 teams.

Schrodizzy

12/16/24 6:48am

That could work, but only if you can effectively eliminate "conference strength" bias. Which is near impossible.

unctoothman

12/16/24 9:00am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad