I can make an argument that says yes.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 8, 2024
12:18:52am

Allstate All-American

I can make an argument that says yes.

We tied Iowa St. for first in the regular season. Conference tiebreaker formula shouldn't be the reason to put one team ahead of another in the rankings. We have a recent common opponent in ASU to compare how each team played. We have a better win than ISU.

Report problem with this ad

Allstate

Previous username: FootBackwards
Bio page: Allstate
Joined: Sep 10, 2007
Last login: Dec 26, 2024
Total posts: 3,019 (6 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So stupid that the CFP Committee has backed themselves into a corner not wanting

Y05

Dec 7, 3:05pm

I believe that Kansas is better than Vandy and KU would beat them easily

acougfan

Dec 7, 3:06pm

Kansas wasn't even a bad loss. We should have won though. It's criminal how low we are ranked going into this week

Colorado

Dec 7, 3:09pm

18th is where we should be if we had 3 losses

Timeout Husbander

Dec 7, 3:11pm

Kansas was a bad loss

Coug

Dec 7, 3:13pm

They also beat Colorado and Iowa State. They aren't Mew Mexico

Colorado

Dec 7, 3:15pm

Yup, a "good loss" to NIU is the CFP preference.

Les IsMore

Dec 7, 8:49pm

The problem is the Big XII now has no “logos” It may take a few years before new

Hoopster

Dec 7, 3:10pm

Gotta beat Kansas. Can’t get past that loss.

RenoCoug

Dec 7, 3:29pm

Yep. Of course, multiple playoff teams gonna make it with equal or worse losses.

YbeatsU

Dec 7, 3:34pm

Apply that logic to everyone and you won't find 12 teams to complete the

Y05

Dec 7, 3:39pm

Most teams in the Top 12 don't have an equivalent loss and if the do

RenoCoug

Dec 7, 4:22pm

We are 18. Do the same with the 13-17. There is no justification for us not being close to 12 and we would have a

Colorado

Dec 7, 4:49pm

Alabama does (maybe even two), and they have three losses.

chilawcoug

Dec 7, 8:45pm

*most

RenoCoug

Dec 7, 9:00pm

So, it's not "can't"? It's just "they don't want to get past it"?

chilawcoug

Dec 7, 9:35pm

We are forgetting that the playoff committee actually dropped us to 13 when we

Veep

Dec 7, 4:54pm

No, that's the point of my post. FULL reevaluation.

Y05

Dec 7, 5:52pm

The Kansas lost came after a should have lost to Utah week.

ochobeeguy

Dec 7, 10:51pm

The interesting thing is for teams losing in the conference championship game.

HonestTakes

Dec 7, 5:17pm

Good point

Blue chunks

Dec 7, 7:47pm

I can make an argument that says yes.

Allstate

Dec 8, 12:18am

Including BYU, Kansas beat three ranked teams in a row—they were way better

Srg

Dec 7, 5:56pm

BYU had two winnable games to get in. They lost both

KYU

Dec 7, 6:24pm

Nobody is denying that. The guy just wants a fair evaluation.

Slicey'J

Dec 7, 7:02pm

BYU is not in the top 12. That’s fair

KYU

Dec 7, 7:13pm

It’s also be fair for them to be ranked 12. This has been we’ll-reported by

Slicey'J

Dec 7, 7:35pm

You’re forgetting the part where you do this analysis on every team

conetah

Dec 8, 11:33am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad