The difference between Puka @ Y and Puka @ Rams is enormous and speaks to NFL QB

Dec 2, 2024
3:58:26pm

MrSandman Starter

talent and elite offensive game planning.

BYU does not use their “stars” as they likely should, and current QB is not close to a star

Report problem with this ad

MrSandman

Bio page: MrSandman
Joined: Sep 11, 2022
Last login: Dec 3, 2024
Total posts: 2,237 (17 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Current player I think could go down as one of the best at their position

HimmerFredette

Dec 2, 3:45pm

I love all these guys and they are very good but none come close to best ever

Bluforever

Dec 2, 3:48pm

Chase Roberts?

HimmerFredette

Dec 2, 3:49pm

He's good. Top ten good? I don't know.

cambo

Dec 2, 3:51pm

Name 9 WRs better

HimmerFredette

Dec 2, 3:53pm

RE: Name 9 WRs better

The Y's Insider

Dec 2, 4:09pm

IMO, Roberts is better than Miller (less deep speed) Boyce (lesser speed and

Threw and Through

Dec 2, 6:37pm

Solid list

cajuncoug

Dec 2, 7:52pm

When he's done with the NFL, there won't be 10 BYU receivers with more NFL receiving yards. He's definitely top 10.

HarlemCoug

Dec 2, 8:39pm

IMO, Roberts will struggle in the NFL. He just isn't fast enough.

Lance71

Dec 2, 9:46pm

6’4”, tough, great hands, excellent routes - he’ll make it.

Bluforever

Dec 2, 10:00pm

When you said one of the best, that meant top 2 or 3 to me. Chase is prob top 10

Bluforever

Dec 2, 3:53pm

I meant top 10 for all of them

HimmerFredette

Dec 2, 3:54pm

I think Roberts absolutely fit's the Puka, Collie line of greats...

Coug

Dec 2, 3:52pm

The difference between Puka @ Y and Puka @ Rams is enormous and speaks to NFL QB

MrSandman

Dec 2, 3:58pm

You mean there is a difference between a former #1 overall pick, 15-yr vet ...

Coop

Dec 2, 4:08pm

I didn’t realize J. Hall was a juco transfer. Guess he’ll never sniff the NFL

MrSandman

Dec 2, 6:15pm

Right, that is the proper comparison, and Jaren and Stafford are identical

Coop

Dec 2, 9:02pm

This is a huge issue with Arod. Collie called him out on it

Frankfromtheballpark

Dec 2, 8:41pm

Puka also missed majority of his final year in Provo. I think he shows out a

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 11:20pm

I’d choose JoJo Phillips … needs more reps and will be amazing.

CougFan4EverEver

Dec 2, 3:49pm

You mean JoJo the Drop Ball King?

GoodGuyGary1

Dec 2, 7:16pm

He’s a redshirt freshman.

HiLife

Dec 2, 7:41pm

Micah Simon was a bad WR until he wasn’t

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 8:33pm

Lassiter has lots of drops, too.

Forzaitalia

Dec 2, 9:23pm

Glasker is and will continue to be better than Taggart

SV72 Sale

Dec 2, 4:02pm

I’d put in $100

I'mBatman

Dec 2, 4:07pm

I'd like to think this is pretty close.

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 11:52pm

Any idea how much of the sales revenue goes to the player?

HarlemCoug

8:25am

I firmly believe Glasker has NFL potential. He and Jack Kelly are the only two I

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 6:33pm

Lassiter, Roberts, and JoJo do as well IMO

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 8:35pm

I can see JoJo developing into an nfl guy. You lose me with Roberts and Lassiter

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 11:18pm

Well, someone that must have some credibility is whispering the contrary to

Jasbo

Dec 2, 11:27pm

Probably a mix of NFL agents and a desire to be done with college ball.

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 11:40pm

Milne made a roster multiple years and these two aren’t any worse than him

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 11:55pm

Milne is a tough comp imo. He, like Zach, benefitted greatly from the 2020

Riseandshoutboys

12:04am

Taggart led us in tackles coming into the ASU game,

Threw and Through

Dec 2, 6:56pm

Wow thats crazy to have that kind of speed at inside linebacker

RUNBYU1

Dec 2, 8:27pm

You think any of those guys could be top 5 all-time at their position?

Projectoor

Dec 2, 4:39pm

Marion is probably a top 5 all time KR after this year. Definitely pushing it

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 6:16pm

He’s returned a couple for TD’s but he’s also tried to return about 25 over past

Bluforever

Dec 2, 6:38pm

An extra 80 yards every once in a while makes up for tons of 5 yard losses

y2kougar

Dec 2, 10:11pm

Not for me. We started in the hole far too many times; it’s tough to drive 80 yd

Bluforever

Dec 2, 10:19pm

Statistically it’s much better, trust me

y2kougar

Dec 2, 10:57pm

I’m not sure enough of those are on him for it to matter

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 11:37pm

Agree re: Glasker

cajuncoug

Dec 2, 7:59pm

Ferrin

ochobeeguy

Dec 2, 10:09pm

Jakob Robinson is a Top 5 CB at BYU.

dYrtbYkerYder

Dec 2, 10:17pm

He is the one from this year's team. He was phenomenal.

kimdaddy35

Dec 2, 11:47pm

What kicker would be picked over Will Ferrin with the game on the line?

Kolipoki

Dec 2, 10:31pm

I think you’re right. But if I had to choose one kicker to deliver a big hit…

Reasonable1

Dec 2, 10:37pm

Totally agree. If Payne is in the HoF then they should already be prepping

Kolipoki

Dec 2, 11:06pm

I don’t want a kicker to hit. I want one to clutch kick. Payne cost

pappabear246

12:18am

He was not as good as a young Jake Oldroyd. So hopefully he can stack some seasons together.

Posting on CougarBoard