Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up
Dec 2, 2024
10:34:14am
krindorr Truly Addicted User
BYU 2025 Roster - Early Look and Portal Needs

Lots of talk about "we squandered our opportunity" or "we arrived a year early", so wanted to take a VERY early look at next year. Obviously a lot to come with transfers (both in and possibly out) and signings and early declarations for the draft, but this should give a quick look at where we stand and where we need help for next season.  This is very rough obviously, just a very first look

Position 1st String

2nd String

Notable or Potential Losses
QB Jake Retzlaff (RS SR)

Treyson Bourguet (RS JR)
McCae Hillstead (RS SO)
Noah Lugo (RS FR)

Gerry Bohanon (Eligibility)
RB

LJ Martin (JR)
Sione Moa (SO)

Enoch Nawahine (RS SR)
Pokaiaua Haunga (SO)

Hinckley Ropati (Eligibility)
WR

Keelan Marion (RS SR)
JoJo Phillips (RS SO)
Parker Kingston (RS JR)

Kody Epps (COVID SR)
Cody Hagen (RS FR)
Dominique McKenzie (RS FR)

Darius Lassiter (Eligibility)
*Chase Roberts (Early Declare?)
TE Ethan Erickson (RS SR)

Noah Moeaki (RS FR)
Jackson Bowers (RS SO)

Mata'ave Ta'ase (Eligibility)
Keanu Hill (Eligibility)
Ryner Swanson (Mission)
Mason Fakahua (Eligibility)

OL

Isaiah Jatta (RS SR)
Weylin Lapuaho (SR)
Bruce Mitchell (JR)
Sonny Makasini (JR)
Austin Leausa (SR)

Ethan Thomason (FR)
Jake Griffin (RS SO)
Jake Eichorn (RS SR)
Ikanasio Tupou (RS FR)
Trevin Ostler (RS JR)
Joe Brown (RS FR)

Caleb Etienne (Eligibility)
Brayden Keim (Eligibility)
Conner Pay (Eligibility)

 


So to summarize the offensive situation

  • QB is pretty good with Retzlaff returning, could definitely use someone to step up as the #2 or QB of the future... but tough to get that in the transfer portal. 
  • RB is good and young with solid depth and a wide spread of eligibility. Like QB, being better wouldn't hurt, but it's not the priority that other positions are
  • At WR, it hurts to lose our top 2 WR (Roberts and Lassiter), but Phillips, Marion, Kingston have plenty of experience and Hagen + McKenzie have upside.  Wouldn't rule out adding an established starter here, but should be OK even if we don't. And if we manage to get Roberts back, then this is a huge strength.
  • TE is a bit of a massive hole, will almost certainly need to address via the portal. It would be nice to see Bowers take a step forward but can't count on it at this point
  • OL loses a LOT with three departing starters. I made the choice to move Leausa to RT and Makasini to RG, but I'd guess this is also a portal target.  Young guys behind them haven't really shown much yet, so this is a spot we could use both immediate and long-term help.  Thomason, Brown, Tupou have upside but likely aren't ready to be instant impact

 

Position 1st String 2nd String Notable or Potential Losses
DE Boodie Schoonover (RS JR)
Sani Tuala (JR)

Viliami Po'uha (RS FR)
Ephraim Asiata (SO)

Tyler Batty (Eligibility)
Isaiah Bagnah (Elgibility)
Logan Lutui (Eligibility)

DT

Joshua Singh (RS SR)
Luke To'omalatai (SR)

David Latu (RS JR)
John Taumopeau (RS JR)
John Nelson (Eligibility)
Blake Mangelson (Eligibility)
LB

Isaiah Glasker (RS JR)
Harrison Taggart (RS JR)
Jack Kelly (RS SR)

Sione Moa (RS SR)
Ace Kaufusi (JR)
Siale Esera (RS SO)
*Jack Kelly (Early Declare?)
CB

Evan Johnson (RS JR)
Therrian Alexander (SO)
Jonathon Kabeya (SO)

Marcus McKenzie (JR)
Jayden Dunlap (RS SR)

Marque Collins (Eligibility)
Jakob Robinson (Eligibility)
Mory Bamba (Eligibility)

S

Crew Wakley (RS SR)
Tanner Wall (RS SR)

Raider Damuni (JR)
Tommy Prassas (SO)
Faletau Satuala (RS FR or SO)
Tanner Alfrey (RS SR)
Ethan Slade (RS SR)

 
K

Will Ferrin (RS SR)

Matthias Dunn (RS SO)

 
P

Sam Vander Haar (RS JR)

Landon Rehkow (RS SO)

 

 

So on defense and ST

  • The defensive line is the biggest issue.  DE is unproven, with young guys to be excited about (Asiata and Po'uha), but we lose our top three edge rushers.  DT generally lacks ceiling, with more experienced backups moving into larger roles behind departing starters.  Like TE it would be nice to see Ice Moa take a step forward, but I don't think we can count on it.  Honestly, he's more likely to move on in the portal (same with Bowers). I'm guessing we'll be looking for immediate contributors from the portal at both DE and DT.
  • LB is rock solid - realistically the biggest problem may be retaining them all.  We're at a point where Kaufusi, Esera, Moa have been around for a while and might want to go somewhere where they can get more time.  That's especially true if Kelly comes back.
  • CB has young talent but lacks proven quality.  Some guys that we're excited about (see Alexander and Kabeya)... but probably a spot we'll want to bring in at least one clear starter
  • I have no idea what to make of S.  I had to list two starters, so I went with the two currently at the top, but honestly wouldn't be totally surprised by any of the 7 listed there taking a starting role.  It's tempting to say we could use some portal help there, but with SO many upside names, I don't think it will be the priority. More likely to have a few move on and settle out the rotation
  • Kicker and Punter are fine.  They've been strong and will continue to be

 

This message has been modified
Originally posted on Dec 2, 2024 at 10:34:14am
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 2, 2024 at 10:48:56am
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 2, 2024 at 12:41:39pm
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 2, 2024 at 12:44:25pm
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 2, 2024 at 12:45:39pm
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 2, 2024 at 12:47:16pm
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 2, 2024 at 5:28:25pm
Message modified by krindorr on Dec 18, 2024 at 6:59:52am
krindorr
Bio page
krindorr
Joined
Oct 5, 2020
Last login
Dec 25, 2024
Total posts
19,823 (128 FO)
Related Threads Children:
Early look at the 2025 BYU roster and portal needs. What do you see as BYU’s biggest need? (@CougarBoard, Dec 2, 2024 at 4:08pm)

Messages
Author
Time
krindorr Truly Addicted User
Dec 2, 10:34am
Dec 2, 11:56am

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.