They put BYU, Arizona St., Iowa St., Kansas St., and Colorado all in the top 25, and then they completely ignore any and all wins between those teams as being a positive. Boise St. gets a lot of traction over having a close loss to Oregon. And then BYU gets very little credit for beating ranked teams in SMU and Kansas St. while 1 of their 2 losses coming on the road against a ranked Arizona St. team. They are essentially getting punished for close wins vs. Oklahoma St. and Utah (while the committee completely ignores Notre Dame's loss to NIU and inexplicably throws a 2-loss Tulane team ahead of BYU when Tulane hasn't beaten a single ranked team this year).