My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 20, 2024
9:11
:06
am
pinolero
All-American
You can't call him a game manager and not consider his entire game. Just say hes
an above average passer if all your discussing is passing.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
pinolero
Bio page
pinolero
Joined
Mar 16, 2008
Last login
Nov 20, 2024
Total posts
6,113 (2 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
JR now ranks 23 out of 33 in career pass efficiency in the last 50 seasons at BYU (and climbing) Impressive.
byuTX
mutual friends
8:30am
Seems a shame we didn't get a year of Baylor Romney
Beggar
8:37am
Is it? The G5 opponent merchant? No thanks.
TCuz
8:41am
Might have been a better fit than Slovis last year
Beggar
8:43am
He would have taken snaps from Hall or Wilson so he was in a rough spot to be a full time starter.
byuTX
8:42am
His PER this season is 140 which would put him at #15 with Feterick. I dont
pinolero
8:38am
That would be great. I think he is limited to game manager by talent, decision making & coaching. 140 is 50th nationally
byuTX
8:41am
And 140 only accounts for passing. He's good with his legs too, deserve credit.
pinolero
8:58am
Correct. In a discussion about passing, passing is what we are discussing ;). He can be a good runner at times. I wish
byuTX
9:02am
You can't call him a game manager and not consider his entire game. Just say hes
pinolero
9:11am
He’s a slightly above average passer overall. He’s a gritty game manager. (Sometimes mismanager like Saturday)
byuTX
9:44am
Sometimes I wonder if the great story of the 1st Jewish QB @ BYU plays
88Coug
8:44am
People love a great storyline from a fan perspective. ARod trusts very few
stansburycoug
9:14am
"Inability to hit 30+ yards" is such a weird, mistaken take it makes me wonder
oxcoug
9:50am
Based on just this season, he's ahead of 2014 Stewart, 1999 Feterik, 2007 Hall
donnerstag
8:45am
Sure. And I agree if you throw out his worst year he’s better than many other QBs’ worst years
byuTX
8:48am
<< Deleted >>
oxcoug
8:54am
Is this adjusted for strength of schedule? If not I dont know how relevant the
Junior Deputy
9:37am
It is not. If you compare to P4 teams this year he is #31 (there are 70 P4’s). Very much average
byuTX
9:51am
Sure, but your OP is comparing him to historical BYU QBs. Which is fine, and fun
Junior Deputy
9:56am
Yep. That’s a limitation of the comparison for sure. The only real comparisons are all subjective. I don’t think JR is a
byuTX
10:04am
Game winning drives at SMU, Utah, and vs Ok St - can still improve a lot
RWaters
10:01am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad