I know. All time teams tend to skew to the more recent, that is just the way it is. Luckily, we had guys win major

Report problem with this ad

Nov 11, 2024
9:32:39am

shimmy In play, run(s)

awards and have major accomplishments so we aren’t just relying on folk lore.

Report problem with this ad

shimmy

Previous username: AFCoug83
Bio page: shimmy
Joined: Jan 15, 2008
Last login: Nov 16, 2024
Total posts: 122,075 (37,872 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Current players that would make the all time BYU first team-

shimmy In play, run(s)

Nov 11, 9:29am

Will Ferrin which I concur, has ice in his veins

MajorZeus

Nov 11, 9:30am

It's hard to make comparisons for a lot of Coug fans that never lived the 70-90s

EM_Puma

Nov 11, 9:31am

I know. All time teams tend to skew to the more recent, that is just the way it is. Luckily, we had guys win major

shimmy

Nov 11, 9:32am

Agree. Robinson has been insanely good this year. Oates and Matich may have a

Ferb

Nov 11, 9:31am

Oates and March are ones where it would be tough to parse, but you’re probably right.

shimmy

Nov 11, 9:34am

Not sure anyone would make the team this year

Projectoor

Nov 11, 9:32am

Love Connor, but Bart Oats and Trevor Matitch would like a word.

d-coug

Nov 11, 9:32am

Starting LB groups is the best we have had. Have had better individual players

johnnybyu

Nov 11, 9:34am

I dunno about better than the kvn years. That group was insane- but these guys are good.

shimmy

Nov 11, 9:36am

What about Leon White and Kurt Gouveia?

SierraCoug

Nov 11, 9:44am

That was a good group

johnnybyu

Nov 11, 6:40pm

Not sure about players, but Poppinga can coach the All-Time ST unit

LeonMarek

Nov 11, 9:34am

And Gilford can coach the Corners.

LeonMarek

Nov 11, 9:36am

KM having the highest average return is pretty awesome.

shimmy

Nov 11, 9:37am

I know it's only been 2 years, but Jay Hill can coach the defense

SV72 Sale

Nov 11, 9:42am

Here’s what’s crazy. If you had the all time defensive team coached by our last

blackandblue

Nov 11, 9:36am

Jakob Robinson is absolutely there. The guy is unreal and locks down his guy

kimdaddy35

Nov 11, 9:41am

Robinson can also hit and tackle in the open field. He is of my all time favorites.

Posting on CougarBoard