Nov 10, 2024
6:34:07pm
RalphWiggam Barkeep, another Mekong please
I’m tired of hearing “controversial holding” in all the writing and discussion
of the play. The holding wasn’t “controversial.” There is no controversy. It was an indisputable penalty. Full stop. What Vaughn did to JoJo is not permitted within the rules. It was a penalty.

You can say “crucial” or “critical” or “key” penalty in fourth quarter extends BYU’s drive. But not controversial.

I’ve yet to see any non Utah fan look at it and say “yeah…that was clean.” There is no controversy. It was a penalty. It should absolutely have been called. And it also wasn’t a “late” flag in terms of the play. The flag came out before the play was over.
RalphWiggam
Bio page
RalphWiggam
Joined
Feb 3, 2005
Last login
Nov 12, 2024
Total posts
35,027 (2,280 FO)