NIL isn’t a poison apple. Consider everywhere else in the world where athletics

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 1, 2024
7:22:37pm

Reasonable1 All-American

NIL isn’t a poison apple. Consider everywhere else in the world where athletics

is separate from education. Players can be professional athletes from a young age and develop more because of it. They can get an education at the same time but it’s coordinated with their athletic pursuits, not in conflict with their athletic pursuits.

Report problem with this ad

Reasonable1

Bio page: Reasonable1
Joined: Mar 4, 2015
Last login: Nov 1, 2024
Total posts: 7,344 (35 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I hope we aren't overpaying for Dybantsa, because Bill Self thinks so

nova_coug_fan

5:57am

If your not paying for him, why do you care?

Magneto

6:00am

People keep saying this, and the answer is obvious- there isn't unlimited NIL

nova_coug_fan

6:06am

If you pay attention to what has been leaked, it is very clear that our big donors are willing to give extra to sign

BYUMizzou

6:10am

But who else are we passing up on? KY is recruiting the best players available

robin

6:12am

This is probably the most persuasive counterargument to me

nova_coug_fan

6:17am

Every team would want AJ if they had the resources. Next year we have those

Magneto

6:56am

Meanwhile we're going to pull in a 2nd consecutive top 10-15 recruiting class...

icecougar

7:18am

The enthusiasm generated from signing a top recruit will influence others to

joelvandyne

7:22am

That's like saying that once you get married, there's another woman you wont be

anonymous37

7:33am

That is absolutely not how it works. The supply may as well be unlimited

Belboz

7:46am

It's as high as the donors like Ryan Smith are willing to go

Saxa

8:54am

There is also a long game here. This helps with future recruiting and there are many of these NIL contracts that the

8:36am

There are more than enough funds for AJ and others. Fear not.

Thrill

8:45am

If our big donors want to pay - then who am I to stop them?

Saxa

8:53am

I don't think it works that way. Donors didn't like Pope enough to pay more.

Muscle IQ

9:20am

Bill Self has less money to spend.

6:01am

Bill is jealous everyone can buy players now. And he's an Adidas school. Loser.

byubyu

6:06am

Can't imagine anything worse. Unless it were Under Armour.

Hawk in the 303

8:01am

Yes.. UA is wayyyy worse. Just look who they sponsor (coughs Utah coughs)

Saxa

8:54am

Bill Self lost at home to a BYU team w half the talent of this year's team a bit

oxcoug

6:06am

I don't agree with your assumptions. You state that a team signing Dybantsa is getting a one man show and will not be a

BYUMizzou

6:08am

That's easy for him to say at Kansas.

cougargollum

6:09am

The funny thing about this take is no one takes into consideration that the team

ordinary tri guy

6:12am

Kansas is in a much different place than us in CBB. They don't need to make a

LifeLongLakerFan

6:13am

He would know. They overpay for Dickenson.

6:14am

Was the first thing I thought. STILL the most over-hyped player in D1 ball. Gonna go three years running?

SinkingQuffa

6:54am

Do we know his NIL #? (Dickinsons)

VinnyBYU

8:00am

What does having a player like AJ instantly do to BYUs brand? What does it do

Squirt

6:26am

Yes. Kansas already has an established brand. BYU does not. That's why Self

6:38am

Based on that description, it is not overpaying.

Thrill

8:47am

1. He won’t be alone. 2. If we don’t pay him to play for us…

xgbs

6:34am

Gotta give KY the benefit of the doubt

inertiaman

6:42am

You must be mad that Villanova didn’t make his list.

Magneto

6:57am

Demin and Catchings aren't the only ones getting NIL on this team. Getting the

GMGlenn

7:00am

You’re going to hear excuses like this from the programs who lose out on AJ

NOCAL_YFAN

7:08am

He may not end up being the best player in college but he is

davidmj10

7:10am

Also Bill Self himself is overpaid.

davidmj10

7:12am

Why can't you build a team and have the #1 player?

Cthack1

7:11am

sounds like self is unhappy that he can't compete for high end players.

bald man

7:27am

This is a classic example of sour grapes.

Adwight

7:37am

Blue bloods don't like the leveling of the playing field. Just ask Nick Saben

GMGlenn

7:39am

So so true

TNT

9:03am

In the NIL era, everyone is overpaid.

MajorZeus

7:53am

Every championship roster prior to this offseason is largely irrelevant the

8:00am

You can trust Bill Self for Kansas, his team is in a different spot

stansburycoug

8:01am

Bill Self is just mad he can’t pay under the table anymore

coug719

8:10am

I dont care I just want to elevate our basketball influence and have a good

goblin

8:11am

BYU has a much more narrow recruiting net

Projectoor

8:14am

I hope we are

niqmadu

8:16am

The main goal of paying for AJ isn’t a national championship next year

8:22am

1. Sour grapes. 2. Dybantsa would be worth more to BYU than other blue bloods.

Reasonable1

8:30am

I'm not paying anyone anything

boctabulous

8:58am

It's worth it to shell out this kind of money when a university is making a name

BlueFever

9:00am

That’s rich coming from a guy paying kids when it was not legal. I know one of

Big Daddy D

9:16am

Self is the biggest cheater in college basketball. No one should believe a word

dixdog

9:19am

you now have to pay players. I feel very uncomfortable being the highest bidder

ohiocougar

9:21am

How was Alabama football viewed for the past decade? They were the high bidders.

Reasonable1

9:27am

Alabama was great because of coach Saban. And all the 1rd draft picks. This

ohiocougar

10:09am

NIL isn’t a poison apple. Consider everywhere else in the world where athletics

Reasonable1

7:22pm

Lol Crawford? I certainly hope we're not paying for a 4th string pg.

KayakCoug

9:21am

Crawford is not 4th strong and will be a very good switch up at pg with foul

coot20

9:40am

He is our fourth best PG. Egor, Hall, Baker, Crawford, Tre 1-5. All but Crawford

Big Daddy D

9:52am

I am not sure I would really classify Baker as a PG

Projectoor

10:00am

Baker is the one guy on the team who will hunt for his shot. He's a scorer.

Parker Schnabel

4:58pm

I'd take Stewart over Crawford. Crawford is small, dribbles too much.

KayakCoug

11:08am

Why would that be a bad thing? There is no salary cap

Belboz

8:10pm

Interesting this comes out after Kansas isn't on his list anymore. 🧐

RoaroftheCougartails

9:32am

I think NIL will collapse in on itself. Donors will shell out for Dybantsa.

RoboKayne

9:42am

LOL, he's saying that bc he can't have him. He would say the same thing about MJ if he were going to some other school.

BYU Grounds

10:24am

I 100% support what we are doing with AJ. . .but

MyTwoCents

11:12am

True. Also, Kentucky was the apotheosis of this. Their team composition and

RoboKayne

11:21am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad