that's the exact same rating that McCae Hillstead and Gerry Bohanon had on 247, but Gerry is a former conference champion, and McCae had D1 success at USU. Neither was transferring up from a lower division. And Treyson Bourguet was rated higher than all of them.

So yeah, who had the better QB room? And not saying BYU's backups are 5 stars, but they are solid as backups, and experienced at the D1 level.