Puerto Rico, and Costa Maya, and Honduras

My order from best to worst

Best
Curaçao
Antigua
Grand Cayman
Honduras
Puerto Rico
Cozumel
Belize
St. Kitts
Aruba
Costa Maya
Jamaica

Jamaica was the absolute worst. A bunch of them are very similar. Aruba was like wendover with a beautiful ocean.

Curaçao was the most unique and most memorable for me. And we scuba dove most of these islands.