What I don’t understand is why

Sep 30, 2024
10:17:24pm

spooky Redshirt Freshman

Why Grimes/Arod worked so well but now both are struggling with nearly the same gameplan as before.

I do give Arod credit though for a much improved offense this season

Report problem with this ad

spooky

Bio page: spooky
Joined: Aug 25, 2020
Last login: Sep 30, 2024
Total posts: 129 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

We will see a Jay Hill-type improvement on offense as soon as Arod is replaced

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 9:53pm

With who?

cambo

Sep 30, 9:56pm

Ty Detmer? Max Hall? Taysom?! There are so many to pick from.

Crowd Factor

Sep 30, 9:57pm

They don’t have to be active LDS like the HC— bring in someone dynamic and innov

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 9:58pm

Make some meaningful suggestions. You seem to know the criteria on what you're sure would be an upgrade

CLCougar

Sep 30, 10:00pm

He's actually already given a lot of suggestions. See link.

rcbyufan

Sep 30, 10:15pm

You seem to have the answers. So who?

cambo

Sep 30, 10:00pm

agreed. And remember that half the conference wants to fire their OCs right now

runnincoug

Sep 30, 10:08pm

And within a year CB will be calling for his head

icecougar

Sep 30, 10:48pm

Diff game now, budgets will let BYU get real talent like Hill & Kevin Young

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:16pm

Aaron rodgers

spooky

Sep 30, 10:10pm

lol. You said the same thing when mark poop left

Haysom Till

Sep 30, 10:14pm

Andy Reid

Shihan

Sep 30, 11:48pm

…our fanbase is waaaay too long-suffering 😂 …and trust me, we’ve suffered long

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 9:56pm

Whereas Auburn on the other hand. . .

Crowd Factor

Sep 30, 9:57pm

What I don’t understand is why

spooky

Sep 30, 10:17pm

No, but we saw one when he took over play calling.

dYrtbYkerYder

Sep 30, 9:57pm

Clown post bro

macdizzle

Sep 30, 9:59pm

Not at all… prove me wrong instead of personal attacks

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 10:00pm

You haven't said anything of substance to even refute.

rcbyufan

Sep 30, 10:02pm

Prove yourself right with some solid and realistic upgrades rather than speaking in vague generalities. We'll evaluate

CLCougar

Sep 30, 10:02pm

Who's out there better is not a good argument

stansburycoug

Sep 30, 10:06pm

Like who?

cambo

Sep 30, 10:12pm

Any G5 OC or FCS head coach with a good offense. This isnt like picking a HC

stansburycoug

Sep 30, 10:22pm

This is very much what I have in mind- a high powered G5 OC. We wont know

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:24pm

I'm just asking you to give me a freaking name!

cambo

1:17am

Your whole post was a whiny angry opinion.

GfB

Sep 30, 10:04pm

Sounds like a personal attack without any refuting facts

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 10:12pm

5-0

cougarbob137

Sep 30, 10:05pm

…offense has been bailed out by the D in nearly every game, sorry bro

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 10:11pm

Retzlaff was the better QB in every matchup and the highest graded QB in the

cougarbob137

Sep 30, 10:23pm

SIU & Wyo games padded Retzlaff's stats... I think he threw for like 40yds in

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:04pm

You want to talk about facts but then countered with mere opinion.

LifeLongLakerFan

Sep 30, 11:28pm

uuuh, where is any opinion listed there. I stated Retzlaff's stats have been

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:54pm

Alright. There are some facts. Here are some other facts.

LifeLongLakerFan

12:10am

...you're correct. I think Sagarin has us at #17 sos

Das_Countach

12:32am

I’d love specific examples of play calls you feel were incorrect, with some

macdizzle

Sep 30, 10:22pm

Our offense has much less to do with the OC than the QB

2FarGone

Sep 30, 10:00pm

It could be better, but it could be much worse. Be careful what you wish for.

VACougMD

Sep 30, 10:01pm

Look how quickly ARod is turning around the Offense in one season right now.

kccougar

Sep 30, 10:02pm

Fixing the offense is as simple as building a great OL.

ManicBlue

Sep 30, 10:05pm

And look at how much a single coaching change did for Etienne and the line this

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 10:14pm

Only you would take that as a win. smh

ManicBlue

Sep 30, 10:26pm

Under the direction of Coach Roderick. Yup.

kccougar

Sep 30, 10:27pm

lol, well why couldnt Arod help Funk then... sorry bro, you're wrong

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 10:49pm

<< Deleted >>

LifeLongLakerFan

12:17am

Probably not!

shimmy

Sep 30, 10:04pm

Why anyone would want to replace any coach on a 5-0 team makes no sense at all.

Logancoug

Sep 30, 10:04pm

That sounds logical at first. But it’s simplistic if you think about it for more than five seconds.

Brisco

Sep 30, 10:09pm

Why would we be anxious to replace a guy who has put FOUR QBs in the NFL?

runnincoug

Sep 30, 10:12pm

Jay Hills don’t grow on trees. And, for all the success Whittingham has had at Utah, I don’t think he’s never had…

Brisco

Sep 30, 10:05pm

Das ist dumm

The Pope

Sep 30, 10:06pm

He needs help recruiting

Archaea

Sep 30, 10:11pm

Recruiting is like 60% of his job and he's awful at it and why as long as he is

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:19pm

Kellen Moore when and if it happens. But can’t complain at 5-0 and I’m no

Forbidden Fruit

Sep 30, 10:13pm

And Andy Reid?

cambo

Sep 30, 10:16pm

Yeah those two are on the same level

Forbidden Fruit

Sep 30, 10:17pm

Kellen Moore is never coming to coach at BYU. He just isn't.

cambo

Sep 30, 10:21pm

Forbidden Fruit

Sep 30, 10:34pm

Why would Kellen Moore ever come to BYU unless he gets fired? He’s on track to

Cougarite

Sep 30, 10:22pm

Yes and said can’t complain. Just offering a pipe dream option. I mean I don’t

Forbidden Fruit

Sep 30, 10:32pm

Jay Hills recruits weren’t that much higher than what we were getting.

Cougarite

Sep 30, 10:25pm

oh really? Jay's top 8 recruits last year averaged 88.5, Arods were

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 10:47pm

The offense has plenty of talent. If there is a weakness, it is the offensive

byusage

Sep 30, 10:54pm

Defense is way more stacked than offense, and many are freshmen that Hill just

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:01pm

WR group is better than perhaps any BYU has ever had. Oline has made really

Bald Eagle

Sep 30, 11:18pm

...yes, O Line has made big strides (drum roll pls) ...due to a coaching change!

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:27pm

Question: do you think Arod’s offense is watered down and/or simplistic?

Refugee

Sep 30, 10:32pm

And later whining about personal attacks in this thread?

StarMan

Sep 30, 10:37pm

Okay Run along - back to the kids table

Johnny Vatos

Sep 30, 11:02pm

Let them finish the year.

Plantagenet

Sep 30, 11:15pm

I agree, let Arod finish the year, but I have a feeling, more people will agree

Das_Countach

Sep 30, 11:35pm

Dude this mediocre offense by almost all offense statistics has had a

TempeCoug

Sep 30, 11:47pm

there was no where to go but up from last season... how about we compare it to

Das_Countach

12:13am

In 2021 we averaged 33 points per game. Guess what, that what we’re averaging

TempeCoug

12:31am

...defense and special teams has created a big part of that

Das_Countach

12:33am

Do we wait for the end of the season or fire him during our undefeated season?

Reasonable1

Sep 30, 11:54pm

first off, lol at an undefeated season... because that means we're Nat champs

Das_Countach

12:15am

Fire a coach midseason while you’re undefeated…

Reasonable1

12:20am

...never said midseason... go back and reread

Posting on CougarBoard