Detmer was a redshirt Freshman.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 29, 2024
9:08:47pm

ManicBlue Truly Addicted User

Report problem with this ad

ManicBlue

Bio page: ManicBlue
Joined: Jan 10, 2005
Last login: Sep 29, 2024
Total posts: 51,407 (940 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I think Wilson is done

Black Diamond Bay All-American

Sep 29, 12:22pm

For a true freshman, I think he's been formidable.

EM_Puma

Sep 29, 12:24pm

He's statistically one of the worst QBs in the FBS. Zach Wilson was way way

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Sep 29, 12:27pm

I have no idea why CB has such a love affair with lil Wilson

tacallaway

Sep 29, 12:30pm

Retzlaff is actually one of the better QBs in FBS believe it or not. Chart

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Sep 29, 12:32pm

I'm surprised to see SMU's Jennings ranking so we'll on that chart. He didn't

OlanchoCoug

Sep 29, 12:49pm

Turns out BYU's defense is pretty good. Avery Johnson didn't look good either.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Sep 29, 12:57pm

Week 5 only

Charles Darwin

Sep 29, 1:16pm

Didn't he win at Okla State?

Plantagenet

Sep 29, 5:46pm

Is W/L a QB stat or a team stat?

tacallaway

Sep 29, 5:55pm

Zach also played nowhere near this competition. Remember NIU?

arcawley

Sep 29, 12:31pm

He had nowhere near the supporting cast. Matt Hadley was his best running back

YIsForBrigham

Sep 29, 12:32pm

Sure. But Arizona has 2-3 1st round picks on their team. They’re really good

arcawley

Sep 29, 12:34pm

*Utah's defense went on the road and did enough to win in Stillwater

tacallaway

Sep 29, 12:35pm

Is our current stable of healthy backs that much better than Hadley?

Cooouuugs

Sep 29, 6:14pm

He’s also playing in Utah’s offense.

Dryfire

Sep 29, 12:32pm

"Formidable" is a stretch, but it's way too early to pass final judgment

CommodoreCoug

Sep 29, 12:28pm

I don't think he's done. He will be a good QB. But yes, he looked good early and then AZ started getting hits on him

P-Boy Squad

Sep 29, 12:25pm

He might be a good QB IF he transfers. QBs don't improve over time with the utes.

ManicBlue

Sep 29, 12:27pm

He was getting crushed all game

Charles Darwin

Sep 29, 12:25pm

He’s done some things that impress me. His style is a lot like Zach’s pros and

Tuskaloosa Cougar

Sep 29, 12:27pm

That’s possible. But I think it’s way to early to write his football obituary.

gwalker

Sep 29, 12:28pm

Detmer played some as a freshman--and wasn't very good, if memory serves.

Plantagenet

Sep 29, 5:48pm

Detmer showed flashes from the moment he stepped on the field, kinda like

jaba166

Sep 29, 7:41pm

Detmer was a redshirt Freshman.

ManicBlue

Sep 29, 9:08pm

Done for this year. He will be ready take over once rising decides to stop

kansascougar

Sep 29, 12:29pm

I consider that to be a huge piece of this prediction. He's in the middle of a head game right now, with everyone eyeing

Black Diamond Bay

Sep 29, 12:39pm

He looks very talented to me. I wish BYU had him

Belboz

Sep 29, 12:37pm

Maybe we will. BYU is a much better place for a QB. I could totally see him

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Sep 29, 12:59pm

He is small. Probably 180 not 200 and he routinely ended up being crushed by 300

byusage

Sep 29, 12:43pm

He might still be in the ice bath…

thirdgencoug

Sep 29, 4:07pm

He took some big hits.

runningryan

Sep 29, 2:34pm

He had a bad game as a true freshman. It’ll happen and should be expected.

Your Royal Blueness

Sep 29, 2:43pm

He threw a bit of a hissy fit

davidsonlaw

Sep 29, 3:37pm

Probably the sign of a competitor who cares

JoeExotic

Sep 29, 7:50pm

If there was a sliver of a chance of Rising playing, I think he would have. He

truecougster

Sep 29, 4:44pm

I guess that's a possibility. Mostly, that's a lot of creative writing.

BYUDM93

Sep 29, 4:48pm

Maybe. Time will tell. He wouldn't be the first, or the last QB to get thrown into a bad situation and fizzle out. I

Black Diamond Bay

Sep 29, 5:14pm

He made some big time throws. Not done

texaskevin

Sep 29, 5:17pm

He looks to me like a gamer. I wouldn't count him out.

Plantagenet

Sep 29, 5:51pm

That’s a bad take. Wilson isn’t afraid of contact.

davidmj10

Sep 29, 6:03pm

I hope Utah cuts him…and BYU picks him up… silly thought

cougarmikey

Sep 29, 6:16pm

This post will not age well

KYU

Sep 29, 7:03pm

If you think he’s done because he took a few big hits and threw a couple INT you

bookofdaniel

Sep 29, 7:25pm

Hope he comes to BYU

grosven

Sep 29, 8:46pm

So you’re saying Wilson is done based on a few snippets you watched?

Str8CashCougar

Sep 29, 8:47pm

He really stares down his receivers…..

BYU4eVeR

Sep 29, 8:50pm

Such a ridiculous, an knowledgeable take.

Love Cougs

Sep 29, 8:50pm

KW is ruthless. He ran Rising too much and he will ruin Wilson. Next man up

fan32

Sep 29, 9:22pm

I'm all for Utah developing him before he transfers to BYU

archie

Sep 29, 9:22pm

He has shown me more than I thought he'd produce. I think he'll be a talented D1 QB for sure. Growing pains are going

Posting on CougarBoard