You're making the wrong argument

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 27, 2024
9:42:22pm

A_blue_car All-American

You're making the wrong argument

People don't want the game officiated via video and replay, otherwise the replay rule would be worded such to correct bad or missed calls.

That's not the role of replay and that's the reason this is bad. May as well just remove refs if that's the intent you're looking for.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 27, 2024 at 9:42:22pm

Message modified by A_blue_car on Sep 27, 2024 at 9:43:15pm

Report problem with this ad

A_blue_car

Bio page: A_blue_car
Joined: Mar 19, 2017
Last login: Sep 27, 2024
Total posts: 2,655 (113 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

No ref was even close to be able to call a td. Correct call.

Idacoug

9:35pm

Doesn't really matter if a ref was in position to call it or not. The call was

SUAVO

9:36pm

I’ve never seen that context make them take call on the field less seriously

Warner

9:36pm

Yeah, the 2 guys back there weren’t exactly hustling.

CougGolf

9:36pm

That’s not how it work. they made a call on the field and that should have stood

BamaCoug

9:36pm

Good on the ref to make the correct call regardless.

Idacoug

9:37pm

Not how it works.

mulletino

9:38pm

Tell that to the ref who just made the correct call.

Idacoug

9:39pm

Is he in the room with you right now?

Samsonite

9:40pm

Good mature comeback. Go listen to the prophets talk a year ago.

Idacoug

9:42pm

Is the prophet also in the room with you right now?

Samsonite

9:44pm

Dang. You need to get off this board and breathe.

Idacoug

9:45pm

That’s cool you think they made the right call. It’s just not how the rules work.

mulletino

9:40pm

Tell that to the ref that made the call then.

Idacoug

9:41pm

RE: Tell that to the ref that made the call then.

mulletino

9:42pm

RE: Tell that to the ref that made the call then.

Idacoug

9:43pm

You realize that’s a weird reply, right?

Samsonite

9:42pm

No. He made the right call.

Idacoug

9:43pm

Ends justify the means, if you know you’re right… that’s how it works right?

Samsonite

9:43pm

Ref was right. Sorry.

Idacoug

9:44pm

Do you always believe rules should be disregarded if you really believe you’re

Samsonite

9:45pm

I believe the right call was made in that specific situation.

Idacoug

9:48pm

RE: I believe the right call was made in that specific situation.

mulletino

9:56pm

You do realize it was impossible for the ref to be right. He had to break the

rha1211

9:56pm

Actually that’s what makes the ref a bad ref.

MHOP

9:40pm

But they were close enough to call it incomplete? I don’t get your logic

TADOW

9:36pm

Once a call is made you have to have clear and obvious evidence to overturn. It

Cougar TD

9:37pm

It was a mistake. They overturned their mistake. Correct call.

Idacoug

9:38pm

And broke the rules to do it.

DiamondMo

9:40pm

🤣

Idacoug

9:45pm

So you would disregard the rules if you were a ref, based on your feelings?

Samsonite

9:47pm

Based on logic and fact.

Idacoug

9:49pm

Since when does everyone have same perspective of logic and fact...

MHOP

9:51pm

Some people are just black/white thinkers.

Samsonite

9:52pm

terrible take. This is laterally a game governed by rules. Your premise is rules

rha1211

9:58pm

RE: 🤣

MHOP

9:49pm

Doesn't work that way. Opinions go out the window. Indisputable evidence is need

Cougar TD

9:40pm

I know it’s hard for some types to understand, but you can just make up rules

Samsonite

9:41pm

You're making the wrong argument

A_blue_car

9:42pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad