Exactly. The ref with the best view of it that should have had the ultimate

Sep 22, 2024
8:54:27pm

westsidecoug All-American

rule on it signaled him short. Johnson was even arguing with the ref that he thought he scored. No ref on the field signaled TD.

Report problem with this ad

westsidecoug

Bio page: westsidecoug
Joined: Aug 14, 2003
Last login: Sep 22, 2024
Total posts: 16,545 (23 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Okay but hear me out - hear me out...

CougarLegend

2:19pm

RE: Okay but hear me out - hear me out...

CougPrime

2:20pm

Yeah, finally seeing the TV replay made me even more confused. I feel like

westsidecoug

2:22pm

What I don't get is why they got it on the 10 yard line. If he was out

jaba166

5:15pm

They called holding on the OL

eyebleedblu

5:17pm

The ruling was holding. They took the penalty and moved back 10 yards.

refunder

5:19pm

OK, I see. Missed that. Thanks!

jaba166

6:01pm

Penalty pushed it back. Question was if BYU should decline and take the ball

Socrates Johnson

8:25pm

It was super close. Had they called him out it would have stood as called. There was one angle that looked definitive

Haysom Till

2:24pm

Who called him in was my question

WorfoSAUR

2:26pm

This - I assumed the call on the field was out because of that signal

CougPrime

2:29pm

Avery was even mad at the ref because he told him he was out

YIsForBrigham

2:43pm

This was so confusing! I don't think anyone signaled a TD!

Great38

3:37pm

Exactly. The ref with the best view of it that should have had the ultimate

westsidecoug

8:54pm

One angle, definitive = indisputable.

StarMan

2:27pm

There was no ref that signaled TD

maxpowers

2:49pm

That's the thing about angles. When you get the right one it's clear.

TailgateU

8:48pm

They left it on the big screen in stadium for quite some time. Obviously out

O Gaucho

2:25pm

In the stadium I watched the sideline ref and he marked him short. No touchdown signal was ever given. 🤷🏼‍♂️

TANK

2:29pm

Yeah it was bizarre didn’t make any sense

ABCoug

2:36pm

Some of the angles were unclear, I wonder what they were able to review

Projectoor

2:41pm

I agree. But I was actually ok with giving them 3 and getting the ball back at

blackandblue

2:54pm

If nothing else, it can nullify claims of BYU winning by too much home cooking.

Forzaitalia

3:01pm

Must not have qualified as indisputable. I was stunned too.

IronPotato

3:27pm

ESPN announcers were so convinced they were having the discussion around the

Samurai Jack

4:58pm

I was telling my friend during the game as the three other officials stood on

stoils

6:11pm

Is there accountability for refs? I’m not mad in the least. But bizzare things

ColonelMustard

5:01pm

Yes there is. Every call and missed call is reviewed and graded.

Conan

5:56pm

The game announcers and other officials

BYUvermont

5:28pm

Is there a video clip of it?

Conan

5:58pm

RE: Okay but hear me out - hear me out...

coug4evah2347

6:05pm

Blessing in disguise. Probably would have turned it over at the one

gp232

6:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad