I agree. Here’s an article about it

Sep 21, 2024
11:56:41am

Future_Tacos All-American

Why Christopher Tolkien Hated Peter Jackson's Lord Of The Rings Movies

Christopher Tolkien, son of J.R.R. Tolkien, had a passionate dislike of Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy - but what was the issue?

https://screenrant.com/christopher-tolkien-estate-hated-peter-jackson-lord-rings/

Report problem with this ad

Future_Tacos

Previous username: Bonemachine
Bio page: Future_Tacos
Joined: Feb 7, 2005
Last login: Sep 21, 2024
Total posts: 11,656 (25 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Rings of Power season 2 is pretty cool. Much more interesting than season 1.

Benfica1

11:36am

It is if you ignore the lore that is pretty clear that no one knows who is writing that show.

Adrielle

11:39am

I don’t get this.

Future_Tacos

11:45am

How did they stray from the LOTR material? Seems about as close to the actual

RGGeemer

11:53am

I agree. Here’s an article about it

Future_Tacos

11:56am

So he thought they "cut too much". I mean that's what happens when you make a

RGGeemer

11:59am

I think it is clear that nothing was going to please CT

Y'zcrack

12:47pm

I love the movies, but:

Shinshin

12:08pm

RE: I love the movies, but:

Future_Tacos

1:02pm

I was one who didn't like parts of the movies at first, but then I just decided

Shinshin

12:03pm

I’m rewatching season 1 to prep for season 2. Following much better this time.

blueaussie

12:05pm

It had to be loosely tied I believe because they didn’t purchase the rights

Slicey'J

11:50am

I'm enjoying it so far. I never got into the Silmarilion (sp?), and don't remember anything from any footnotes in the

dilbert

11:51am

I'm liking it but never was a true LOTR devotee (Rings of Power Spoiler)

Why Christopher Tolkien Hated Peter Jackson's Lord Of The Rings Movies

Posting on CougarBoard