It’s Pretty impressive that since 2004 only one player has had a higher WAR in

Sep 20, 2024
7:50:39am

bluecougar1985 All-American

a season than Aaron Judge this year. It was Aaron Judge in 2022. He is certainly a generational player. Doesn’t even really have a peer right now.

Report problem with this ad

bluecougar1985

Bio page: bluecougar1985
Joined: Dec 10, 2015
Last login: Sep 20, 2024
Total posts: 16,620 (1,673 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It’s Pretty impressive that since 2004 only one player has had a higher WAR in

bluecougar1985

7:50am

RE: It’s Pretty impressive that since 2004 only one player has had a higher WAR in

crimedog

7:52am

And this does not take away from the absolutely insane year judge has had

crimedog

7:52am

Ohtani is really good. But will only win the mvp because the mlb awards 2 Should

bluecougar1985

7:55am

Plus Shohei moved to the NL so Judge has a chance to rack up some MVP hardware

Methusaleh22

7:56am

Judge would be the landslide winner if it was an entire mvp award.

bluecougar1985

7:58am

except he wouldn't.

crimedog

8:01am

Why would the voters vote for the distant second place player?

bluecougar1985

8:04am

I get that you don't like the dodgers that's fine. But to say Ohtani is a distant 2nd place is hilarious.

crimedog

8:08am

His offensive year is not nearly as good as Judge’s.

bluecougar1985

8:12am

If we can set aside any trolling for a minute, Judge would win but there would

Methusaleh22

8:14am

It wouldn’t be unanimous, but in the end I doubt it’d be very close.

bluecougar1985

8:17am

Maybe. But you said he has no peer. The head to head MVP race would suggest

Methusaleh22

8:03am

He’s great in the regular season. Not so much in the postseason.

garyfan

8:04am

Feeling insecure?

LifeLongLakerFan

8:13am

2004 . . . Barry Bonds, the GOAT of baseball.

materialized

8:44am

The GOAT of PEDs

Posting on CougarBoard