The problems aren't limited to one game or one series. Each game/player/series has ups and downs.. but the pattern and trends are clear. Those raising alarm about ARod are doing the same as those who were pushing for Tuiaki to go.
It isn't personal or vindictive. It is all about what is happening in games, season to season, series to series. Just like with Tuiaki, there are many serious red flags with ARod's offense. We are far too talented to perform so poorly game after game, season after season.

We already saw how holding on to Tuiaki hurt the team... People don't want us to make the same error with ARod when the body of evidence is clear.