My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 8, 2024
10:50
:00
am
byuTX
mutual friends
That’s silly. We have all the proof we need that JR can’t do it now & 3 guys that have at least been competent. Bench JR
And fire ARod. Don’t extend sitake and if he doesn’t improve by the end of the year (he can’t so he won’t) then move on from Sitake
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
byuTX
Previous username
TEXAS
Bio page
byuTX
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Last login
Nov 9, 2024
Total posts
74,970 (41,368 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Retzlaff has a career 7:10 TD to turnover ratio. 7:15 if you include his fumbles that BYU recovered. 4:10, 4:14 vs FBS.
byuTX
mutual friends
Sep 8, 8:46am
It’s not sustainable
Idacoug
Sep 8, 8:47am
Playing an FCS QB with a P4 schedule usually isn’t
byuTX
Sep 8, 8:48am
Do we have any non fcs qbs on the roster?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 8:50am
We have three that have had much more success than JR
byuTX
Sep 8, 8:51am
So they aren’t fcs qbs? Whew excellent. Once those guys come in, we
NYCougz
Sep 8, 8:56am
We have two that are at least G5 (an upgrade) and one that was P4 in the past (also likely an upgrade)
byuTX
Sep 8, 9:09am
Didn’t that p4 play for south Florida last year?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 9:14am
Because Retzlaff is objectively terrible
NanoFab Coug
Sep 8, 9:18am
And the guy who threw as many ints as TDS last year at s Florida
NYCougz
Sep 8, 9:21am
That was south florida
NanoFab Coug
Sep 8, 9:48am
People are using his success at Baylor.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 10:19am
That’s silly. We have all the proof we need that JR can’t do it now & 3 guys that have at least been competent. Bench JR
byuTX
Sep 8, 10:50am
Seriously?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 10:51am
How many games do you need? He’s 0 for 5 in showing he’s an FBS QB
byuTX
Sep 8, 10:54am
So we are using last years games
NYCougz
Sep 8, 10:56am
GB has shown in the past that he is capable. JR has never shown anything but terrible. 0 is less than 1. Hillstead 1>0
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:00am
Why didn’t he beat JR?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:04am
Not sure that matters as these coaches lack judgment. Do you agree JR was and is bad?
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:07am
Your judgement is better?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:11am
Mine, almost all fans and all neutral observers all have better judgment re Retzlaff. Do you think JR is bad?
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:17am
He stunk Saturday.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:19am
And all 4 last year. His numbers were slightly better vs SMU than last year. The time to move on was spring.
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:19am
Right but GB stunk last year
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:21am
Not missing. We don’t know how he will do at BYU. Nor do we know how the other transfers or Lugo will do. All should
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:23am
We have different players as well.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:24am
Retzlaff is the one making it an obvious choice
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:58am
lol! Based on your analysis.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 12:34pm
I think you’ve sufficiently outed yourself as JRs family member…
NanoFab Coug
Sep 8, 12:37pm
Well no offense but you use one game from this year
NYCougz
Sep 8, 12:47pm
No im not.
NanoFab Coug
Sep 8, 12:53pm
Lots of QBs are getting benched. You should watch CFB. It’s fun and you see how functional teams and QB’s operate
byuTX
Sep 8, 12:47pm
Who?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 12:53pm
Where. Who got benched based on one horrible game?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 12:55pm
lol. One horrible game
byuTX
Sep 8, 12:56pm
This year - both had bad games last year.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 12:57pm
JR was the worst QB in 50+ years heading into the season (pass eff., min 100 passes). He’s so bad. SMU game “he stunk”
byuTX
Sep 8, 12:59pm
So using mostly last years stats in his first year as a starter
NYCougz
Sep 8, 1:03pm
You take it all into consideration. Hoping for something better trumps playing known bad. JR shouldn’t see a snap until
byuTX
Sep 8, 2:28pm
Lol… k dude. Like I said you will be benching quarterbacks every 14 days.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 3:06pm
Proof he could do it in the past >>>>>>>> proof JR can’t in the present, future
byuTX
Sep 8, 10:46am
But last year doesn’t matter?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 10:50am
It matters. Which is why we know Retzlaff can’t do it. You try GB this week. If he’s the ‘23 version go to Hillstead
byuTX
Sep 8, 10:55am
So how long does GB get before we move on?
NYCougz
Sep 8, 10:56am
Less than the 6 games JR has had
byuTX
Sep 8, 10:59am
We will be out of QBs soon with you at the
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:13am
I’ve been busy in a different state and career. What’s the coaches’ excuse?
byuTX
Sep 8, 11:18am
You are not making much sense.
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:27am
At least you acknowledge you shouldn’t
NYCougz
Sep 8, 11:28am
Something Sitake and I have in common
byuTX
Sep 8, 2:33pm
Ummm okay man … have a good one
NYCougz
Sep 8, 3:11pm
Oh it’s sustainable. Just sustainably losing.
macdizzle
Sep 8, 8:49am
The upshot is fumble recoveries are generally a 50/50 proposition
bythenumbers
Sep 8, 8:48am
Looking on the bright side is going to eventually cost Sitake his job if he can’t figure it out
byuTX
Sep 8, 8:52am
Seems like a reasonable take. If it doesn't happen cause he's just that much better than the others, then the spotlight
unctoothman
Sep 8, 8:55am
And that’s with an offense supposedly designed to limit turnovers.
CougGolf
Sep 8, 9:04am
There is a zero percent chance that Bohanon is worse than Retzlaff... There is no way...
Coug
Sep 8, 9:14am
And if he is worse there are 3 others that deserve a shot over a proven bad JR
byuTX
Sep 8, 10:50am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad