The most well-respected posters on CougarBoard are recognized for their insightful contributions, depth of knowledge, and positive engagement with the community. Based on the information gathered, here are ten of the most respected posters:

1. **El Jefe**: As the site owner and a highly active participant, El Jefe is widely respected for his leadership and involvement [oai_citation:1,Here was the most legendary fall from grace cougarboard has seen](https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=22030817&btn=prev-msg).
2. **Abe Froman**: Known for thoughtful and engaging posts, often highlighting key issues and generating meaningful discussion [oai_citation:2,CougarBoard — Welcome BYU football and BYU sports fans](https://www.cougarboard.com/).
3. **Supercoug**: Valued for his balanced and insightful commentary on a range of topics, including sports analysis [oai_citation:3,Is Kirk Herbstreit the most respected analyst in football? If not, who? (RSL) - CougarBoard.com](https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message-list.html?id=32126568).
4. **Non-mo Coug**: Frequently mentioned for his well-reasoned arguments and respectful engagement in discussions [oai_citation:4,Is Kirk Herbstreit the most respected analyst in football? If not, who? (RSL) - CougarBoard.com](https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message-list.html?id=32126568).
5. **Carnac**: Recognized for his contributions that often bring humor and levity while maintaining a respectful tone [oai_citation:5,Here was the most legendary fall from grace cougarboard has seen](https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=22030817&btn=prev-msg).
6. **RenoCoug**: Praised for his consistent positivity and insightful posts on various sports and community topics [oai_citation:6,CougarBoard — Welcome BYU football and BYU sports fans](https://www.cougarboard.com/).
7. **Indy Coug**: Respected for his knowledgeable posts, particularly regarding BYU sports and related matters [oai_citation:7,CougarBoard — Welcome BYU football and BYU sports fans](https://www.cougarboard.com/).
8. **BlueFever**: Often cited for his well-thought-out posts that contribute significantly to the community’s discussions [oai_citation:8,CougarBoard — Welcome BYU football and BYU sports fans](https://www.cougarboard.com/).
9. **LifeLongLakerFan**: Appreciated for his deep knowledge of basketball and thoughtful commentary on sports topics [oai_citation:9,CougarBoard — Welcome BYU football and BYU sports fans](https://www.cougarboard.com/).
10. **Soupie**: Known for his engaging posts that often spark interesting and constructive conversations [oai_citation:10,CougarBoard — Welcome BYU football and BYU sports fans](https://www.cougarboard.com/).

These posters are respected for their ability to foster constructive dialogue and contribute positively to the CougarBoard community.

One of those names appeared on the 10 most-disliked posters list, which I am NOT going to share. (No, I do not appear on it. Suck it, haters!)