if there is a debate then the 'historical integrity' might not be so great

Report problem with this ad

Apr 2, 2024
10:50:17am

Beggar All-American

if there is a debate then the 'historical integrity' might not be so great

this is a pretty good option but the ELAM ending seems more in line with the spirit of the game. it's what makes most basketball (pick up ball) competitive til the end. you have a specific number to get to rather than waiting for the clock to run out.

Report problem with this ad

Beggar

Previous username: Eastside
Bio page: Beggar
Joined: May 3, 2001
Last login: Oct 17, 2024
Total posts: 34,867 (96 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

You don't need to completely change basketball w/ ELAM ending! One minor change

BlueKarma

Apr 2, 10:45am

I'm all for the Elam Ending. Fixes the fouling issue, and the game always ends

Apr 2, 10:47am

But this changes the nature of the game too much.

BlueKarma

Apr 2, 10:49am

The nature of the game isn't for it to be played in 3-4 second micro bursts.

Apr 2, 10:52am

Agree. I would be OK with your proposal on the option of shots or ball OOB

Tricky

Apr 2, 1:38pm

Is there a fouling issue though? Only if your team is up I guess…

ochobeeguy

Apr 2, 10:48am

This is nice and all until you’re the team down and are trying to come back

arcawley

Apr 2, 10:48am

This is the way the game was played before the idea that you intentionally foul

BlueKarma

Apr 2, 10:52am

So... come back earlier in the game? Don't punish the audience by foul-fest

ryebrye

Apr 2, 2:35pm

if there is a debate then the 'historical integrity' might not be so great

Beggar

Apr 2, 10:50am

It would mean any game with a 10 pt lead and 4 minutes to go is basically over

Corn Pop

Apr 2, 10:50am

I would only consider this if it was fouls in the first 10 seconds of the shot

rcbyufan

Apr 2, 10:51am

Alternatively, they could switch to quarters and ditch the bonus. Just go

Hypnotoad

Apr 2, 10:51am

so why does men's college bball remain the only holdout for quarters?

Beggar

Apr 2, 10:54am

It doesn't fix the end of game fouling issue like he's saying, but the men's

Corn Pop

Apr 2, 10:57am

It changes the end of game to be more like the NBA. The bonus/double bonus is

Hypnotoad

Apr 2, 11:00am

I personally haven't seen being in the double bonus, which can often happen

Corn Pop

Apr 2, 11:06am

It's not just hoping for a miss. 3 pointer vs 2 free throws as well.

ochobeeguy

Apr 2, 11:27am

The coaches are very powerful and fight it

Apr 2, 11:01am

weird

Beggar

Apr 2, 11:06am

When the sport was invented it was with 2 halves, not quarters

CameronG

Apr 2, 11:14am

I disagree, 2x bonus has done nothing to reduce fouls, go back to all 1-and-1

Apr 2, 11:28am

I kinda like this idea. Punish teams who suck at shooting.

Boring

Apr 2, 1:14pm

I'd go to all 1 and 1 and then reduce the number of timeouts each team has

Beggar

Apr 2, 1:22pm

Doesn't matter. The ending isn't going to change, even though I kind of wish it

thewaterboy

Apr 2, 10:56am

Haha that solves nothing. Teams will just foul immediately again, and again, and again.

RdF3

Apr 2, 11:33am

This is my issue with this solution. You go all out to steal the inbound and

m1k3l33

Apr 2, 12:30pm

Another option: Team gets 1 free throw and the ball if the foul is deemed to be

m1k3l33

Apr 2, 12:30pm

I'm sure teams would still foul, but at least they'd have to make an attempt

m1k3l33

Apr 2, 12:33pm

If in the bonus, I’d like to see 3 FTs awarded if the foul happens outside the 3 point line.

trueblueinarizona

Apr 2, 2:08pm

What about having fouls in the back court get 3 FT shots in the last 2 minutes?

Apr 2, 2:32pm

I agree completely, here's my reason

COUGSFAN338

Apr 3, 6:37pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad