I said this during the game. The last time such a horrible decision was made by Kalani was that infamous punt versus Boise State. There's no defending either decision. They were bad gambles.
But what is really funny and ironic is that in neither case did it cost BYU any points. If I remember correctly I think Boise State also went for it on fourth down after they got the ball deep in BYU's territory and turned it over again to us. This time of course Jakob Robinson put on his Superman cape and made a great pick.