My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 24, 2021
9:00
:45
pm
russkiejedi
Intervention Needed
I love the rest of the album, but that song sucks a lot. I don't know that there
is a PF song that I've heard (and I haven't heard all of them) that I like less.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
russkiejedi
Bio page
russkiejedi
Joined
Feb 22, 2005
Last login
Sep 27, 2024
Total posts
140,163 (56,406 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
What is the best "album" of all time?
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:02pm
DSotM is top 5. The Wall could be top 10-20. That’s why Pink Floyd is so great.
pink22
6/24/21 6:04pm
For me, The Queen is Dead by The Smiths is also top 5. Many people will scoff at
pink22
6/24/21 6:06pm
I have this album. Very good stuff.
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:13pm
The Wall is too flabby. Wish You Were Here is better.
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:13pm
I think that’s why it’s so great. So over the top self indulging it’s bizarre.
pink22
6/24/21 6:19pm
It's all personal taste, of course. Some people like Animals the best.
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:21pm
Animals is fantastic. I’d go something like this:
pink22
6/24/21 6:37pm
Not a fan of Obscured by Clouds or Saucerful of Secrets?
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:55pm
I’m a fan of all of them. That was quick work.
pink22
6/24/21 7:12pm
I think you’re right on The Wall. Still a tremendous album. Final Cut is
valleus
6/24/21 6:58pm
So I’m in my 20’s and love plenty of 70s 80s music but I can’t get into Pink
Cosmo4life
6/24/21 7:08pm
Doing drugs with it probably helps 🤷🏼♂️
pink22
6/24/21 7:13pm
Fleetwood Mac - Rumors
tarzan15
6/24/21 6:05pm
Led Zeppelin IV
BlackBart
6/24/21 6:06pm
Love this album.
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:14pm
Physical Graffiti is also great.
Archaea
6/24/21 6:19pm
I'll have to jump in here, seeing that they're my all-time favorite band and...
So it goes...
6/24/21 7:06pm
Why is that?
ReyOso
6/24/21 8:09pm
I find more an American Blues influence in Zeppelins first three albums. Very...
So it goes...
6/24/21 10:21pm
Thats crazy talk. Definitely no on 3 and 5. Maybe on 1 and 2
Backcountry
6/24/21 11:03pm
That's the beauty of III it's different and unique
So it goes...
6/25/21 12:24am
Out on the Tiles is such a great song.
valleus
6/25/21 9:49am
This is a good answer. This post made me listen to it just now. Good stuff.
bag
6/24/21 7:33pm
The Final Countdown by Europe. Hear me out.
sethj250
6/24/21 6:06pm
Here are some I listen all the way through
Y-Zag
6/24/21 6:07pm
All great albums.
Archaea
6/24/21 6:10pm
Boston is always a guilty pleasure.
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:16pm
Subdivisions?
FulhamUte
6/24/21 7:13pm
Yes, I spaced it. Signals is correct.
Y-Zag
6/24/21 8:15pm
I have taste probably a little different from most here. A couple of my favorite
Jay Rick
6/24/21 6:07pm
On Avery Island is also a really good album
Jay Kay
6/24/21 6:24pm
Fellow Pedro the Lion fan over here. Control is amazing.
doctorthunderpants
6/25/21 10:53am
Mine too. I don’t know if I can count how many times I’ve seen him. House shows,
Jay Rick
6/25/21 12:17pm
If your talking albums that are themed—Sgt peppers is up there..if your talking
Squirt
6/24/21 6:07pm
It would be a Broadway show for me. Les Mis.
Cougarrr
6/24/21 6:08pm
Or maybe Disney - Hunchback is incredible.
Cougarrr
6/24/21 6:16pm
Eagles Greatest Hits should be up there w/ FM Rumors.
Soupie
6/24/21 6:10pm
What, no U2 albums? j/k.
Archaea
6/24/21 6:11pm
Because obviously he meant other than U2.
RalphWiggam
6/24/21 6:16pm
So U2 produced the best two albums of all time and the worst two of all time?
Archaea
6/24/21 6:17pm
Nope. Just the best two.
RalphWiggam
6/24/21 6:24pm
Songs of Experience, Pop, and Songs of Innocence are awful. Anything after 1994
Archaea
6/24/21 6:28pm
You’re kidding…this is one of U2’s best songs ever…and one of the newest…
RalphWiggam
6/24/21 7:54pm
Joshua Tree
Q-grr
6/24/21 9:09pm
Pearl Jam 10
LiveCoug
6/24/21 6:13pm
This is a quality answer.
RalphWiggam
6/24/21 7:55pm
Eminem Show
IceBlueCoug
6/24/21 6:13pm
This is the correct answer
I'mnotacber
6/24/21 7:15pm
RE: What is the best "album" of all time?
BigD Coug
6/24/21 6:14pm
Good choices. No Police?
Archaea
6/24/21 6:16pm
Very good list. Thanks for posting.
Jay Kay
6/24/21 6:37pm
Echoes of Harambe by The Internet
BlackBart
6/24/21 6:14pm
Zeppelin 2 or 4 or Protest the Heros Fortress
Backcountry
6/24/21 6:16pm
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy - Kanye West
TCuz
6/24/21 6:17pm
Kanye is one of a kind.
MrClark
6/24/21 7:03pm
Beatles - Double White; U2-Joshua Tree
bob falfa
6/24/21 6:17pm
I’m an unabashed white album fan. Over all other Beatles albums.
Jay Rick
6/24/21 6:17pm
Is there something to be bashful about? It’s genius
BlackBart
6/24/21 6:23pm
I think a lot of Beatles fans put it behind peppers and revolver and probably
Jay Rick
6/24/21 6:32pm
Rocky Raccoon is my favorite Beatles song
Not Even Close
6/24/21 6:42pm
Revolver was a revolution in music, but not their best album.
valleus
6/24/21 6:59pm
Seventh Son of a Seventh Son by Iron Maiden is a great metal album.
ReyOso
6/24/21 6:18pm
"Asia", debut album. Love "every" song on it.
BleedCougarBlue2
6/24/21 6:18pm
The Blueprint deserves a mention.
allaboutthegainz
6/24/21 6:22pm
Beatles…Abbey Road.
Not Even Close
6/24/21 6:24pm
Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, or Urban Hang Suite by Maxwell
BGRTHNUMEGO
6/24/21 6:26pm
Endless numbered days - Iron and Wine
Hoss Bonaventure
6/24/21 6:28pm
Wallflowers—Bringing Down the Horse. Okay, I don’t really think this is the best
Not Even Close
6/24/21 6:30pm
R.E.M. - Automatic For The People
Hambone
6/24/21 6:32pm
Great album.
RalphWiggam
6/24/21 9:10pm
Find The River might be the best
FulhamUte
6/25/21 12:42pm
I don’t usually listen to individual songs on repeat, but there were times my
bluesloth
6/25/21 12:46pm
Another great themed album start to finish is OK computer
Squirt
6/24/21 6:33pm
I like The Bends a bit more, but OK Computer is great too.
Hambone
6/24/21 6:36pm
Kid A for me. Probably tied with ok computer actually.
Bluedarts
6/24/21 7:06pm
Two more: The Band-Music From the Big Pink and Beach Boys- Pet Sounds
bob falfa
6/24/21 6:34pm
The Band by The Band was pretty good. The Very Best of Bob Dylan
toadie
6/24/21 6:39pm
Paul Simon - Graceland
bluesloth
6/24/21 6:37pm
Tom Petty - Wildflowers
bluesloth
6/24/21 6:43pm
Big Ones
BYUALWAYSNUM1
6/24/21 6:50pm
Does this count as an album? Either way…👍
Not Even Close
6/24/21 6:53pm
Probably not. But I loved it.
BYUALWAYSNUM1
6/24/21 6:55pm
White Album. Abbey Road. DSOTM. Ok Computer. American Beauty.
valleus
6/24/21 6:57pm
Scatman's World
JoeExotic
6/24/21 6:58pm
Rush moving pictures
Cosmo4life
6/24/21 7:09pm
Nirvana Unplugged
whoneedscorners?
6/24/21 7:19pm
For me, in no particular order; dsotm, iv, Doolittle, kid a, the white album
Bluedarts
6/24/21 7:27pm
Siamese Dream - Smashing Pumpkins
specsauce
6/24/21 7:35pm
Right now I'd say Rust in Peace - Megadeth.
Jeffacka
6/24/21 8:04pm
IMO, the best thrash album ever made.
Jay Rick
6/24/21 8:12pm
Dark Side can't be it, because Money is garbage.
russkiejedi
6/24/21 8:52pm
RE: Dark Side can't be it, because Money is garbage.
ReyOso
6/24/21 8:59pm
I love the rest of the album, but that song sucks a lot. I don't know that there
russkiejedi
6/24/21 9:00pm
RE: I love the rest of the album, but that song sucks a lot. I don't know that
Bluedarts
6/24/21 9:05pm
Here's a worse Pink Floyd song:
ReyOso
6/24/21 9:12pm
That one probably sucks, too. But Money is not great.
russkiejedi
6/24/21 9:18pm
RE: Dark Side can't be it, because Money is garbage.
Bluedarts
6/24/21 9:04pm
Also, watch it with the wizard of Oz, it comes on right when they open the door
Bluedarts
6/24/21 9:18pm
People will call this a hot take. But you’re correct.
Jay Rick
6/24/21 9:43pm
He's really not though.
Bluedarts
6/24/21 9:46pm
Ranked in the top 10 on a lot of PF lists of best songs.
ReyOso
6/24/21 9:56pm
Those are dumb lists. It's the worst song on Dark Side.
russkiejedi
6/24/21 10:11pm
No accounting for taste, I guess. I think it's great.
ReyOso
6/24/21 10:15pm
Beach Boys Pet Sounds, GNR Appetite for Destruction, Carol King Tapestry,
neboutefan
6/24/21 8:53pm
MOTM1
BYUcrew818
6/24/21 10:57pm
Lou Reed - Transformer
A_blue_car
6/25/21 12:13am
Van Halen I, All of these are great this is the only one I could think of to ad
BYU Grounds
6/25/21 9:57am
One of my all-time favorites. Hard for me to separate it from a lot of nostalgia
Jay Rick
6/25/21 10:13am
Every song on it is good to great.
BYU Grounds
6/25/21 10:25am
I’m with you. All hits and no misses.
Jay Rick
6/25/21 12:19pm
London Calling
TomPetty
6/25/21 12:30pm
The Clash are pretty awesome!
BYU Grounds
6/25/21 12:34pm
Weezer Blue Album, I'd probably make myself pick a different album as best ever
dazcoug
6/25/21 12:38pm
Huge Weezer fan.. I love how people pick Pinkerton over
FulhamUte
6/25/21 12:43pm
Ya, I love Pinkerton, it's definitely more complex musically and emotionally but
dazcoug
6/25/21 12:50pm
Pinkerton is a classic example of people wanting music “ownership.” A big part
Jay Rick
6/25/21 2:24pm
Others on my list: Led Zeppelin II, Dark side of the moon, White Album, Color
dazcoug
6/25/21 12:58pm
I approve of your list
Bluedarts
6/25/21 12:59pm
It's one of the best sing along albums ever.
Bluedarts
6/25/21 1:00pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad