His first year getting real reps and starts was about like Doman's first year. His last year sucked. No single year of his was as good as Doman's senior year. 4000 yds, 41 total TDs, 8 INTs. 160 rating. Taysom 4200 yds, 29 total TDs. 14 INTs. 118 rating. Then he had a partial junior year that was looking decent until he got hurt.
Sucks that the two sample sizes are different, but neither are complete. Hill's is all over the place with only two healthy seasons and one of them sucked. Doman only had that one single season that was really good. Total body of work vs best single performance? I don't know. Hill is way too incomplete to put as a top 10 QB. Like someone else said, athlete for sure, but not QB.