100% correct. Needs to be at least 3 games. Not right to have a single ace

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 2, 2019
3:39:12pm

Scratch All-American

100% correct. Needs to be at least 3 games. Not right to have a single ace

starter control a whole playoff "series." One game in baseball is not a playoff, it's a play-in game.

Report problem with this ad

Scratch

Bio page: Scratch
Joined: Jan 14, 2004
Last login: Jun 26, 2024
Total posts: 12,366 (375 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Nothing in life is more confusing to me than a one game wild card playoff.

pink22

10/2/19 2:55pm

sad thing is its the only time i will watch other teams play besides mine. I

buckeyecougarguy

10/2/19 2:57pm

It's created some of the best games I've watched.

ReggaeCoug

10/2/19 2:59pm

And, like last night, Nats Ace pitcher, and Brewers Ace reliever are the two

10/2/19 2:59pm

Nope!

10/2/19 2:58pm

Then let’s have 16 teams play a one game playoff. Or every team. It just doesn’t

pink22

10/2/19 3:01pm

Do you also hate March Madness?

10/2/19 3:00pm

It’s not even comparable to March madness

pink22

10/2/19 3:01pm

1 game, winner advances, craziness ensues.

10/2/19 3:03pm

I’m glad you think craziness ensues. It’s not crazy at all. It’s stupid.

pink22

10/2/19 5:07pm

As a Padres fan facing a seemingly never-ending playoff drought, I'd take

10/2/19 3:01pm

But you have Machado!

UNLVcougar

10/2/19 3:03pm

But let’s be honest, it’s not really the postseason. One game does not

pink22

10/2/19 3:31pm

It's awesome.

Carnac

10/2/19 3:05pm

It's just how it works in baseball. I love it. I also love that division ties

10/2/19 3:08pm

Was it awesome before the Nats came back last night?

fldnstrm

10/2/19 3:25pm

I was prepared for the loss.

Carnac

10/2/19 3:38pm

It’s dumb especially when the Nats won more games than the Brewers.

pink22

10/2/19 5:03pm

They should make it the WC a two game playoff, with the team with the worse record having to win both

memento

10/2/19 3:07pm

Hot take dude!

10/2/19 3:18pm

Get rid of it completly. Its a prize for not being good enough.

Count Cougar

10/2/19 3:30pm

It's a YOU problem

10/2/19 3:34pm

100% correct. Needs to be at least 3 games. Not right to have a single ace

Scratch

10/2/19 3:39pm

Then win in the regular season. A play-in game is exactly what it is. If you

califcougar

10/2/19 4:32pm

If MLB had balanced schedules, this would be a fair point, but because they don't, it isn't.

memento

10/2/19 4:54pm

100% correct. It’s really dumb when you analyze it

pink22

10/2/19 5:05pm

I wouldn't supporting making the other teams wait for the wild card teams to

garyfan

10/2/19 3:48pm

3 games. 2 days. double header. Home field team chooses games 1&2 at home or 2&3 at home

jollaksentie

10/2/19 4:04pm

It's exciting and gets ratings. Doubt it will change any time soon.

mwcoug

10/2/19 5:15pm

I get it. I just think it’s a dumb idea. Shorten the season to 150 games and

pink22

10/2/19 5:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad