Keep tweaking the question to get the answer you want

Report problem with this ad

Jan 31, 2015
10:15:19pm

Cougarbib

Keep tweaking the question to get the answer you want

Utah beat BYU slightly head-to-head in state
BYU beat Utah badly head-to-toe ad out of state
Nobody beats anybody on a specific canidate if only 1st school offerred

Nationally, most services have Utah about 10 slots ahead of BYU. Neither school has a 4th or a 5 star recruit at this point.

There are 4 days left.

Neither school has an elite class.

BYU slightly edged Utah in class ranking by most services last year.

Now, what exactly was the question?

Report problem with this ad

Cougarbib

Bio page: Cougarbib
Joined: Jul 28, 2003
Last login: Sep 20, 2024
Total posts: 40,950 (111 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I haven't paid attention yet. Will BYU beat Utah for in-state recruits

kccougar

1/31/15 2:48pm

RE: I haven't paid attention yet. Will BYU beat Utah for in-state recruits

jensen

1/31/15 2:50pm

is that because you don't like that word?

BYU '80

1/31/15 3:08pm

RE: I haven't paid attention yet. Will BYU beat Utah for in-state recruits

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 2:54pm

If it ends up like this,

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 3:03pm

How many of the Utah kids had BYU offers and vice versa?

kccougar

1/31/15 3:07pm

RE: How many of the Utah kids had BYU offers and vice versa?

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 3:21pm

I know this was just about in-state guys, but we also have some out-

bluescholar

1/31/15 3:36pm

Not sure what was funny about this Walter. Just stating things as they are

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 3:42pm

So kids with offers from both BYU and Utah overwhelmingly picked Utah.

argus

1/31/15 4:05pm

No.

bluescholar

1/31/15 4:13pm

You can leave it at that and ignore facts and in-depth info that matter, but ya.

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 4:37pm

In state focus is a red herring. I want the best from wherever. If the best

Coogar2

1/31/15 5:25pm

They will as surely as Chase Hansen is transferring to BYU.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 4:48pm

Or Keiffer Longson, Mika Tafua, Dayan Lake, and Tevita Mounga.

bluescholar

1/31/15 4:56pm

too bad utah will give him the Paul Kruger QB tryout

BYU '80

1/31/15 5:13pm

Yeah, the disservice they did to Paul Kruger was unconscionable.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 10:22pm

Knew you'd go that route

BYU '80

1/31/15 10:44pm

Link to your claims?

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:08pm

Witnesses at the one practice

BYU '80

1/31/15 11:21pm

Who were these witnesses at this one practice? Just making stuff up now?

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:32pm

Basketball team has 17 victories

BYU '80

1/31/15 10:49pm

Yes, they are really tearing it up this year.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:09pm

You claimed the recruiting victory was the lone one

BYU '80

1/31/15 11:22pm

Perhaps you are familiar with figurative language... no, I'm sure you're not.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:37pm

Utah might get Gustin...

1/31/15 4:58pm

Did BYU even offer Gustin?

Cougarbib

1/31/15 5:07pm

That wasnt the question.

1/31/15 6:35pm

Actually It Was

Cougarbib

1/31/15 10:08pm

LOL... Really?

2/1/15 10:50am

Last year Utah killed BYU in state. This year both BYU and Utah lost in state.

Scratch

1/31/15 5:08pm

True but out of state where both schools offered BYU killed utah

BYU '80

1/31/15 5:11pm

Really? I don't see anyone that signed with Utah last year from Utah that BYU

bluescholar

1/31/15 5:18pm

Those pesky facts

BYU '80

1/31/15 5:24pm

As has been proven on the field time and time again.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 10:23pm

Yeah those annual blowout nail biters

BYU '80

1/31/15 10:50pm

Please don't go the 'conduct on the field' route, not after the Memphis game.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:16pm

I guess your poorly worded posts leave

BYU '80

1/31/15 11:23pm

Pro tip: When critiquing someone's writing quality, grammar or spelling...

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:43pm

Yeah that post had no facts behind it. BYU +1 in state. +4 or so out of state

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 5:35pm

You think BYU beat Utah in out of state recruits this year? Not so sure

BlueFrog

1/31/15 5:43pm

In head-to-head? Is there even a question? Utah didn't get any.

bluescholar

1/31/15 5:44pm

no. head to head is too hard to determine. too many guys are going to that

BlueFrog

1/31/15 5:46pm

Right, but you're responding to a thread regarding head-to-head and my post was

bluescholar

1/31/15 5:51pm

yeah my original reading was not head to head. just overall. Overall it isnt

BlueFrog

1/31/15 6:02pm

I prefer to actually watch guys play rather than just going off of rankings.

bluescholar

1/31/15 6:07pm

wait, havent you posted several times in this thread who was rated higher than

BlueFrog

1/31/15 6:10pm

Some of both, I've watched every guy I posted about on both sides.

bluescholar

1/31/15 10:58pm

RE: yeah my original reading was not head to head. just overall. Overall it

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 6:12pm

Utah is cleaning up at Defensive Back as well.

BlueFrog

1/31/15 6:15pm

Keep tweaking the question to get the answer you want

Cougarbib

1/31/15 10:15pm

i think both schools have a 4 star

BlueFrog

1/31/15 10:21pm

National Services were not showing it when I looked yesterday

Cougarbib

1/31/15 10:24pm

which service?

BlueFrog

1/31/15 10:26pm

Both schools have 4 star commits.

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 10:30pm

yup - see Scout full Comparison below

Cougarbib

1/31/15 10:41pm

RE: no. head to head is too hard to determine. too many guys are going to that

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 5:56pm

Killed BYU? According to what?

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 5:33pm

Lotuleilei actually wasn't even last year and I've heard from some reliable

bluescholar

1/31/15 5:43pm

Interesting. More to pile on the embarrassing post above. lol

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 5:45pm

I just meant Utah's recruits from Utah were better than BYU's last year

Scratch

1/31/15 6:08pm

Barton as an outlier may be the reason alone

BYU '80

1/31/15 6:25pm

LOL - best recruit in the state is an "outlier" to be disregarded. Perfect.

Scratch

1/31/15 6:32pm

with a small sample size one extreme outlier

BYU '80

1/31/15 10:57pm

If you make an intelligent post I suppose we should disregard it.

Scratch

1/31/15 11:04pm

So you are saying my intelligence

BYU '80

1/31/15 11:11pm

I may be going out on a limb here, but I think he is making fun of you.

Soft Jazz Ute

1/31/15 11:39pm

More. Doesn't necessarily equal better.

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 6:34pm

Utah had more and better. According to Scout, Utah's best was better, Utah's #2

Scratch

1/31/15 6:46pm

Wow you're really looking for a big time win here.

southernfriedcougar

1/31/15 7:15pm

What Services Would That Be that breaks class ranking out by State?

Cougarbib

1/31/15 10:18pm

Rivals and Scout both rank players by state. You can then look and see where

Scratch

1/31/15 10:22pm

on rivals you can filter by state. then add up and divide ratings

BlueFrog

1/31/15 10:23pm

Even so, you cannot judge who did the best by

Cougarbib

1/31/15 10:27pm

<< Deleted >>

bluescholar

1/31/15 10:46pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad