Because there is new information.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 7, 2025
1:50:09pm

Plato All-American

Because there is new information.

Report problem with this ad

Plato

Bio page: Plato
Joined: Mar 21, 2017
Last login: Jan 8, 2025
Total posts: 21,534 (520 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Why was Akana a near 5 star and now as a transfer he’s only a 3 star?

Big12Yfan

Jan 7, 1:48pm

Becuase he signed with Texas and transferred to BYU.

Cougs2012

Jan 7, 1:50pm

Because there is new information.

Plato

Jan 7, 1:50pm

The new information being that he signed with BYU

Bob Vance

Jan 7, 1:57pm

Or he wasn’t able to earn playing time

Jan 7, 2:00pm

Not really binary answers here. All could be reasons

Bob Vance

Jan 7, 3:11pm

He couldn't earn playing time in two years at Texas. A true 5 star talent

RH84025

Jan 7, 1:50pm

Like Arch Manning

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 1:53pm

Well...only if he transferred to BYU. If he transferred to Ol' Miss, he'd still

BlueKarma

Jan 7, 2:01pm

Zero percent chance Manning would be a 3* if he transferred... he would be high 4* at worst

Coug

Jan 7, 2:03pm

He would be a 5 star. I'm just pointing out the fallacy of the argument. Arch Manning would go #1 in the NFL

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 2:15pm

Akana would probably be top 5 if he went…

ochobeeguy

Jan 7, 2:20pm

A guy with one career tackle would go top 5 in the NFL draft??

Jan 7, 2:35pm

Do you read whole threads, or just pick by random?

ochobeeguy

Jan 7, 10:21pm

RE: Akana would probably be top 5 if he went…

Cougz19

Jan 7, 2:57pm

Comparing a QB and DE doesn't prove anything. Lots of DEs typically play in a single game. With QBs, it's super uncommon

Jan 7, 2:33pm

My understanding is that the recruiting sites took a measured action on transfer ratings this year and tried to

P-Boy Squad

Jan 7, 1:52pm

Tausile is the real deal. If he gives 100%, he's gonna be amazing.

grosven

Jan 7, 1:54pm

Because the World is out to screw BYU in any way possible. Especially refs.

foofcoug

Jan 7, 2:00pm

I got shorter, slower and weaker at Texas.

Benfica1

Jan 7, 2:54pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad