He seemed overrated

Report problem with this ad

Dec 16, 2024
7:04:11pm

CaliforniaCougar22 Contributor

He seemed overrated

Yeah he was a 4 star but his offer list was that of a mid 3 star and his on-field performance wasn't any better.

Report problem with this ad

CaliforniaCougar22

Bio page: CaliforniaCougar22
Joined: Nov 25, 2014
Last login: Dec 16, 2024
Total posts: 444 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Aisea Moa entered into the portal.

ByuCrusader

3:13pm

This one hurts, ouch.

runnincoug

3:16pm

I don’t see that, all the LB’s are coming back

JOPE

3:55pm

Ouch

EM_Puma

3:16pm

Yeah, this sucks. He received a fair amount of PT mid-season, but Miles Hall

Das_Countach

4:16pm

Source

ByuCrusader

3:17pm

BYU failed with another top recruit

BYU '80

3:18pm

To me this confirms that Kelly is back. We didn't fail him. We just have some

spidercoug

3:21pm

How did they fail? The guy gets PT, is playing behind three possible next level

BYUheaven

3:22pm

Thinking now though, hall, Esara, Glasker, Taggart all could be here in 2026,

cougaman

3:24pm

Sure….maybe not a sure fire starter but he was progressing well.

BYUheaven

3:28pm

He only has 2 years left though, and probably 5 guys already ahead of him with

cougaman

3:29pm

My bad, for some reason I thought he had three off the top of my head

BYUheaven

3:40pm

<< Deleted >>

BYUfannonLDS

3:34pm

You really have no idea if this is true or not. At least wait for some

LifeLongLakerFan

3:33pm

Look at our history with four star guys.

BYU '80

4:14pm

If a player fails to see the field who exactly failed? It seems byu is developing guys just fine…

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:13pm

What? He hardly saw the field and couldn’t bulk up to d line.

Mjolnir

3:55pm

Isn’t that a failure? We had a 4 star guy

BYU '80

4:21pm

You are reading way too much into the rankings

JKLCoug

5:14pm

It will be used against us with top recruits

BYU '80

6:37pm

Lol - so don’t play the best 11 players, play the highest ranked

JKLCoug

7:08pm

And it happens everywhere

Belboz

10:21pm

Remember the rankings at 24/7 are made by guys who were journalists in college.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:14pm

Top recruits are overrated. Utah has failed with literally every single one of

uteman13

6:13pm

Not sure what to think about this source when they called him an edge rusher

cougaman

3:19pm

Yeah, I think out of HS, he was recruited as an Edge on the DL, but as talented

jaba166

11:21pm

Is it about $$$$$$?

Big12Yfan

3:17pm

Why would be about $ if he was 3rd string?

Mjolnir

3:55pm

*gift cards

CrimWalCoug

4:05pm

Oh no

TNT

3:17pm

Dang… Is this one more about PT or money? He maybe wasn’t going to start next

cougaman

3:19pm

On second thought, I think this is about trying to start. Between Kelly, Glasker

cougaman

3:27pm

Which probably means his 4 star brother won't sign with BYU for 2026.

BYUfannonLDS

3:19pm

We still have his other brother and this is a PT issue. We have 3 NFL caliber

spidercoug

3:20pm

Dang. This is the first one that I’m super bummed about.

ballen

3:20pm

$$$ move

TANK

3:23pm

Isn’t his brother a huge recruit for 2026? If so, that probably hurts as much if

DieHarder

3:26pm

We’ll see if Sione stays though. Maybe the oldest brother can convince him

cougaman

3:28pm

This sucks, but this is new norm in NIL/transfer portal world. Be difficult to

kansascougar

3:28pm

This one’s a bummer

DavisCoCoug

3:34pm

Is it possible BYU will try and bring in Sione Fotu from Utah now?

BYUfannonLDS

3:35pm

If J Hill decides he is better (or anyone else). I trust him at this point

fulano

4:00pm

With his size I thought they might have tried moving him to edge next year. I think he’s got good enough motor to do it.

SolidBlue

4:38pm

He started at edge and was moved.

cougaman

4:52pm

Darn. Sure hope RB Moa does not follow.

Forzaitalia

4:48pm

Why would he? They aren't related.

Rise Against

4:48pm

Not even cousins of some sort?

Forzaitalia

4:52pm

Not any Moa.

CrimWalCoug

5:01pm

Why would he want to leave? PT? Money? Scheme?

Borg

4:48pm

2 years of eligibility, Esera likely passes him up on depth chart next season

Das_Countach

4:52pm

Wasn't he struggling to add weight to his lanky frame and couldn't therefore get the strength needed for DL?

CLCougar

5:08pm

He seemed overrated

CaliforniaCougar22

7:04pm

Too bad, I like that Moa family!

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:15pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad