A year as a backup and then a chance to start in '26 seems reasonable

Dec 10, 2024
1:23:29pm

Huge Manatee Truly Addicted User

He has the talent for sure. But he will have to beat out others and won't just be handed a spot. Hillstead has a year on him in the system, so he is already a bit behind. Might be good for him to have to fight for it.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 10, 2024 at 1:23:29pm

Message modified by Huge Manatee on Dec 10, 2024 at 1:23:38pm

Message modified by Huge Manatee on Dec 10, 2024 at 1:25:21pm

Report problem with this ad

Huge Manatee

Previous username: Bronoc
Bio page: Huge Manatee
Joined: Mar 14, 2011
Last login: Dec 31, 2024
Total posts: 54,369 (5,722 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Issac at BYU is a positive

TJD

12/10/24 1:19pm

Plus he had the stifling KWhitt vicegrips on play calling.

mulletino

12/10/24 1:20pm

Good point. And a OC that was fired (again).

Atmospheric_Cougar

12/10/24 5:00pm

Redshirt him a year and still hope to get Ryder Lyons.

docrick

12/10/24 1:21pm

Lyons is mission bound, so not likely to have much impact on each other

donnerstag

12/10/24 1:42pm

I'm curious about his mindset though. He needs to not feel entitled to be heir

runnincoug

12/10/24 1:21pm

Hopefully he doesn't come in and ruin our locker room like he did the Utes.

kimdaddy35

12/10/24 1:22pm

and this should be a huge red flag.

bald man

12/10/24 1:42pm

I'm not an Isaac fan, but the Utes' locker room was already a house of cards.

slatecoug

12/10/24 4:33pm

I can see that. Why do you think it was a house of cards before?

kimdaddy35

12/10/24 4:33pm

Utah has no team identity, their program has no culture at all

slatecoug

12/10/24 5:07pm

What did he do to their locker room?

SoValleyCOUG

12/10/24 4:33pm

One of our Utah posters said he partied a lot, even on game eves.

rockhound

12/10/24 7:44pm

There's a rumor that he threw a punch at one point.

dYrtbYkerYder

12/11/24 7:27am

If a true Freshman can ruin your locker room; then it’s already a dumpster

SwanSong

12/10/24 4:34pm

Jake Heaps didn't help us much as a sophomore

kimdaddy35

12/10/24 4:39pm

You aren't referring to the satire twerk about Isaac punching someone are you?

MaximusMeridius

12/10/24 5:22pm

I didn't see that tweet, but I have heard from about 7 different sources that he caused some issues

kimdaddy35

12/10/24 6:57pm

Meaning he sucked and the defense was mad that the offense sucked

MaximusMeridius

12/10/24 10:50pm

I prefer to think the Utah locker room ruined him

Great38

12/10/24 5:52pm

Sounds like we need to hear the rest of the story

DazeofBlue

12/10/24 6:42pm

A year as a backup and then a chance to start in '26 seems reasonable

Huge Manatee

12/10/24 1:23pm

He'll be grateful for a good coach and any opportunity

Mike Bolton

12/10/24 1:23pm

I know there are rumors, but an reputable sources say it's BYU where he lands?

macdizzle

12/10/24 1:24pm

Yes I think it’s on the Rancheritos sign on State St.

Ron Mexico

12/10/24 1:29pm

I'm not that interested, TBH. He is undersized, and too much drama there

Iman23

12/10/24 1:31pm

The drama at Utah seems manufactured to me

arcawley

12/10/24 1:42pm

The drama already existed. Did we forget the OC was fired halfway through?

Atmospheric_Cougar

12/10/24 5:01pm

I'd have to think his stock and market NIL price are down right now.

Cougarclaw

12/10/24 1:32pm

Buy low!

byuinva

12/10/24 5:25pm

I’m fine with bringing him in to compete with Hillstead and others but I doubt

WillsPitStop

12/10/24 1:34pm

He hasn't done enough to be guaranteed at a P4 school.

mudpupper

12/10/24 1:36pm

I agree but I doubt that he and his family sees it that way.

WillsPitStop

12/10/24 1:38pm

No legit coach is going to let him have the job without competition

donnerstag

12/10/24 1:44pm

He is short. look how often our passes are being bated down

bald man

12/10/24 1:42pm

To be fair he also battled injuries and an incompetent offense

arcawley

12/10/24 1:43pm

Our current QB has passes being batted down, so what’s the difference

arizonacougarfan

12/10/24 2:49pm

Release point is much higher than Retzlaff’s, which makes up for multiple inches

byuinva

12/10/24 5:27pm

But Retzlaff's teammates actually like him which makes up for multiple yards.

Black Diamond Bay

12/10/24 6:38pm

RE: But Retzlaff's teammates actually like him which makes up for multiple

byuinva

12/11/24 10:23am

I think he's good enough to bring into the program, but I wouldn't spend any

Mister P

12/10/24 1:46pm

He kinda sucks.

DudeBro

12/10/24 1:47pm

As long as he's a gym rat like his brother, he's a value add to the room

donnerstag

12/10/24 1:48pm

Did BYU sign I Wilson, or is this just a hypothetical set of comments?

Forzaitalia

12/10/24 2:23pm

The latter. Welcome to CB.

Cougar Junkie

12/10/24 3:15pm

He struggled but he threw some dimes too. He eventually got overwhelmed and hurt

pinolero

12/10/24 2:26pm

I don't care about his size, I care about his processing speed

deliciousmocha

12/10/24 2:30pm

He played for an offense so bad the coordinator quit during the season. Two star

SwampyCoug

12/10/24 2:36pm

This might be counting chickens before they hatch

Brandoblueblood

12/10/24 2:37pm

Other than Locked on Big 12, who else is saying Isaac to BYU?

CougMAGA

12/10/24 2:49pm

He won't have first string reps this upcoming year either. Low risk, high reward depending on what kind of NIL $ he got

TheLoneCougar

12/10/24 3:06pm

RE: Issac at BYU is a positive

It's A Bowling Ball

12/10/24 3:25pm

Rose and Bottari also didn't get any first team reps, and they were improvements

The Toolman

12/10/24 4:03pm

Pass, would like someone else!!

Blue for Life

12/10/24 4:08pm

IMO if he was 6’2” like his bro you couldn’t tell them apart on the field. The

gp232

12/10/24 5:35pm

Zach's arm is much, much stronger than Isaac's. Even as a Freshman.

dYrtbYkerYder

12/11/24 7:28am

Where’s the announcement?

kapcreations

12/10/24 6:01pm

I say let him go…Freshman or not, kid looked out of sorts

SoggyBB

12/10/24 7:12pm

RE: I say let him go…Freshman or not, kid looked out of sorts

Cooouuugs

12/10/24 8:19pm

Give the kid a chance

44C

12/10/24 9:13pm

How soon can these kids sign with a new team?

imdocrob

12/11/24 10:51am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad