He was overrated out of high school because of his brother (this was obvious to everyone). He played a big part in fracturing the locker room at Utah (how many sources do you need?)
These are all facts.
You think he is still good and can contribute at BYU. Maybe, none of us know the answer to that for sure. I will be sad if that is the direction that we go. You obviously think he is the greatest QB in the history of the world.